C++ - 是否可以在单元测试中实现内存泄漏测试？

Question

我正在尝试为我的代码实施单元测试，但我很难做到。

理想情况下，我想测试一些类，不仅是为了良好的功能，而且是为了正确的内存分配/释放。 我想知道这个检查是否可以使用单元测试框架来完成。 顺便说一句，我正在使用Visual Assert 。 如果可能的话，我很想看到一些示例代码！

Answer 1

您可以直接在 dev studio 中使用调试功能来执行泄漏检查 - 只要您的单元测试使用 debug c-runtime 运行。

一个简单的例子看起来像这样：

#include <crtdbg.h>
struct CrtCheckMemory
{
  _CrtMemState state1;
  _CrtMemState state2;
  _CrtMemState state3;
  CrtCheckMemory()
  {
    _CrtMemCheckpoint(&state1);
  }
  ~CrtCheckMemory()
  {
    _CrtMemCheckpoint(&state2);
    // using google test you can just do this.
    EXPECT_EQ(0,_CrtMemDifference( &state3, &state1, &state2));
    // else just do this to dump the leaked blocks to stdout.
    if( _CrtMemDifference( &state3, &state1, &state2) )
      _CrtMemDumpStatistics( &state3 );
  }
};

并在单元测试中使用它：

UNIT_TEST(blah)
{
  CrtCheckMemory check;

  // TODO: add the unit test here

}

一些单元测试框架会进行自己的分配——例如，当单元测试失败时，Google 会分配块，因此任何由于任何其他原因而失败的测试块也总是会出现误报“泄漏”。

Answer 2

您可以使用 Google 的tcmalloc分配库，它提供了heapchecker 。

（请注意，堆检查可能会显着增加程序性能的开销，因此您可能只想在调试版本或单元测试中启用它。）

你要求提供示例代码，所以这里是.

Answer 3

1. 经过对我的一些调查并基于 Chris Becke 的非常好的解决方案（适用于 Windows），我为 Linux OS 制作了一个非常相似的解决方案。

2）我的内存泄漏检测目标：

非常清楚 - 同时检测泄漏：

2.1) 理想情况下以精确的方式 - 准确指示分配了多少字节但尚未释放。

2.2) 尽力而为——如果不准确，以“误报”方式指出（告诉我们泄漏，即使不一定是泄漏，同时不要错过任何泄漏检测）。 最好在这里对自己更加苛刻。

2.3) 由于我在 GTest 框架中编写单元测试 - 将每个 GTest 单元测试作为“原子实体”进行测试。

2.4) 还要考虑使用 malloc/free 的“C 风格”分配（解除分配）。

2.5) 理想情况下 - 考虑 C++“就地分配”。

2.6) 易于使用并集成到现有代码中（用于单元测试的基于 GTest 的类）。

2.7) 能够为每个测试和/或整个测试类“配置”主要检查设置（启用/禁用内存检查等）。

3. 解决方案架构：

我的解决方案使用了使用 GTest 框架的继承功能，因此它为我们将来添加的每个单元测试类定义了一个“基”类。 基本上，基类的主要功能可以分为以下几部分：

3.1) 运行“第一个”GTest 样式测试，以了解在测试失败的情况下在堆上分配的“额外内存”量。正如 Chris Becke 在上面回答的最后一句话中提到的。

3.2) 易于集成——简单地从这个基类继承并编写你的单元测试“TEST_F 风格”函数。

3.3.1) 对于每个测试，我们可以决定是否另外声明执行内存泄漏检查。这是通过 SetIgnoreMemoryLeakCheckForThisTest() 方法完成的。 注意：无需再次“重置”它 - 由于 GTest 单元测试的工作方式（它们在每次函数调用之前调用 Ctor），它会在下一个测试中自动发生。

3.3.2) 另外，如果由于某种原因你事先知道你的测试会“错过”一些内存释放并且你知道数量 - 你可以利用这两个函数来考虑这个事实，一旦执行内存检查（顺便说一下，通过“简单地”从测试结束时使用的内存量中减去测试开始时使用的内存量来执行）。

下面是头文件基类：

// memoryLeakDetector.h:
#include "gtest/gtest.h"
extern int g_numOfExtraBytesAllocatedByGtestUponTestFailure;

// The fixture for testing class Foo.
class MemoryLeakDetectorBase : public ::testing::Test 
{
// methods:
// -------
public:
    void SetIgnoreMemoryLeakCheckForThisTest() { m_ignoreMemoryLeakCheckForThisTest= true; } 
    void SetIsFirstCheckRun() { m_isFirstTestRun = true; }

protected:

    // You can do set-up work for each test here.
    MemoryLeakDetectorBase();

    // You can do clean-up work that doesn't throw exceptions here.
    virtual ~MemoryLeakDetectorBase();

    // If the constructor and destructor are not enough for setting up
    // and cleaning up each test, you can define the following methods:

    // Code here will be called immediately after the constructor (right
    // before each test).
    virtual void SetUp();

    // Code here will be called immediately after each test (right
    // before the destructor).
    virtual void TearDown();

private:
    void getSmartDiff(int naiveDiff);
    // Add the extra memory check logic according to our 
    // settings for each test (this method is invoked right
    // after the Dtor).
    virtual void PerformMemoryCheckLogic();

// members:
// -------
private:
    bool m_ignoreMemoryLeakCheckForThisTest;
    bool m_isFirstTestRun;
    bool m_getSmartDiff;
    size_t m_numOfBytesNotToConsiderAsMemoryLeakForThisTest;
    int m_firstCheck;
    int m_secondCheck;
};

这是这个基类的来源：

// memoryLeakDetectorBase.cpp
#include <iostream>
#include <malloc.h>

#include "memoryLeakDetectorBase.h"

int g_numOfExtraBytesAllocatedByGtestUponTestFailure = 0;

static int display_mallinfo_and_return_uordblks()
{
    struct mallinfo mi;

    mi = mallinfo();
    std::cout << "========================================" << std::endl;
    std::cout << "========================================" << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Total non-mmapped bytes (arena):" << mi.arena << std::endl;
    std::cout << "# of free chunks (ordblks):" << mi.ordblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "# of free fastbin blocks (smblks):" << mi.smblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "# of mapped regions (hblks):" << mi.hblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Bytes in mapped regions (hblkhd):"<< mi.hblkhd << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Max. total allocated space (usmblks):"<< mi.usmblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Free bytes held in fastbins (fsmblks):"<< mi.fsmblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Total allocated space (uordblks):"<< mi.uordblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Total free space (fordblks):"<< mi.fordblks << std::endl;
    std::cout << "Topmost releasable block (keepcost):" << mi.keepcost << std::endl;
    std::cout << "========================================" << std::endl;
    std::cout << "========================================" << std::endl;
    std::cout << std::endl;
    std::cout << std::endl;

    return mi.uordblks;
}

MemoryLeakDetectorBase::MemoryLeakDetectorBase() 
    : m_ignoreMemoryLeakCheckForThisTest(false)
    , m_isFirstTestRun(false)
    , m_getSmartDiff(false)
    , m_numOfBytesNotToConsiderAsMemoryLeakForThisTest(0)
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::MemoryLeakDetectorBase" << std::endl;
    m_firstCheck = display_mallinfo_and_return_uordblks();
}

MemoryLeakDetectorBase::~MemoryLeakDetectorBase() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::~MemoryLeakDetectorBase" << std::endl;
    m_secondCheck = display_mallinfo_and_return_uordblks();
    PerformMemoryCheckLogic();
}

void MemoryLeakDetectorBase::PerformMemoryCheckLogic()
{
    if (m_isFirstTestRun) {
        std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::PerformMemoryCheckLogic - after the first test" << std::endl;
        int diff = m_secondCheck - m_firstCheck;
        if ( diff > 0) {
            std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::PerformMemoryCheckLogic - setting g_numOfExtraBytesAllocatedByGtestUponTestFailure to:" << diff << std::endl;
            g_numOfExtraBytesAllocatedByGtestUponTestFailure = diff;
        }
        return;
    }

    if (m_ignoreMemoryLeakCheckForThisTest) {
        return;
    }
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::PerformMemoryCheckLogic" << std::endl;

    int naiveDiff = m_secondCheck - m_firstCheck;

    // in case you wish for "more accurate" difference calculation call this method
    if (m_getSmartDiff) {
        getSmartDiff(naiveDiff);
    }

    EXPECT_EQ(m_firstCheck,m_secondCheck);
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::PerformMemoryCheckLogic - the difference is:" << naiveDiff << std::endl;
}

void MemoryLeakDetectorBase::getSmartDiff(int naiveDiff)
{
    // according to some invastigations and assumemptions, it seems like once there is at least one 
    // allocation which is not handled - GTest allocates 32 bytes on the heap, so in case the difference
    // prior for any further substrcutions is less than 32 - we will assume that the test does not need to 
    // go over memory leak check...
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::getMoreAccurateAmountOfBytesToSubstructFromSecondMemoryCheck - start" << std::endl; 
    if (naiveDiff <= 32) {
        std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::getSmartDiff - the naive diff <= 32 - ignoring..." << std::endl;
        return;
    }

    size_t numOfBytesToReduceFromTheSecondMemoryCheck = m_numOfBytesNotToConsiderAsMemoryLeakForThisTest + g_numOfExtraBytesAllocatedByGtestUponTestFailure;
    m_secondCheck -= numOfBytesToReduceFromTheSecondMemoryCheck;
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::getSmartDiff - substructing " << numOfBytesToReduceFromTheSecondMemoryCheck << std::endl;
}

void MemoryLeakDetectorBase::SetUp() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::SetUp" << std::endl;
}

void MemoryLeakDetectorBase::TearDown() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorBase::TearDown" << std::endl;
}

// The actual test of this module:


TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorBase, getNumOfExtraBytesGTestAllocatesUponTestFailureTest) 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::getNumOfExtraBytesGTestAllocatesUponTestFailureTest - START" << std::endl;

    // Allocate some bytes on the heap and DO NOT delete them so we can find out the amount 
    // of extra bytes GTest framework allocates upon a failure of a test.
    // This way, upon our legit test failure, we will be able to determine of many bytes were NOT
    // deleted EXACTLY by our test.

    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::getNumOfExtraBytesGTestAllocatesUponTestFailureTest - size of char:" << sizeof(char) << std::endl;
    char* pChar = new char('g');
    SetIsFirstCheckRun();
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::getNumOfExtraBytesGTestAllocatesUponTestFailureTest - END" << std::endl;
}

最后，一个示例“基于 GTest”的单元测试类，它使用这个基类并说明用法和几个不同的 POC（概念证明）到各种不同的分配和验证，如果我们能够（或不能）检测到遗漏的 de - 分配。

// memoryLeakDetectorPocTest.cpp
#include "memoryLeakDetectorPocTest.h"
#include <cstdlib>  // for malloc

class MyObject 
{

public:
    MyObject(int a, int b) : m_a(a), m_b(b) { std::cout << "MyObject::MyObject" << std::endl; }
    ~MyObject() { std::cout << "MyObject::~MyObject" << std::endl; }  
private:
    int m_a;
    int m_b;
};

MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest" << std::endl;
}

MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::~MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::~MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest" << std::endl;
}

void MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::SetUp() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::SetUp" << std::endl;
}

void MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::TearDown() 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::TearDown" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyNewAllocationForNativeType) 
{

    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForNativeType - START" << std::endl;

    // allocate some bytes on the heap and intentially DONT release them...
    const size_t numOfCharsOnHeap = 23;
    std::cout << "size of char is:" << sizeof(char)  << " bytes" << std::endl;
    std::cout << "allocating " << sizeof(char) * numOfCharsOnHeap << " bytes on the heap using new []" << std::endl;
    char* arr = new char[numOfCharsOnHeap];

    // DO NOT delete it on purpose...
    //delete [] arr;
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForNativeType - END" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyNewAllocationForUserDefinedType) 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForUserDefinedType - START" << std::endl;

    std::cout << "size of MyObject is:" << sizeof(MyObject)  << " bytes" << std::endl;
    std::cout << "allocating MyObject on the heap using new" << std::endl;
    MyObject* myObj1 = new MyObject(12, 17);

    delete myObj1;
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForUserDefinedType - END" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyMallocAllocationForNativeType) 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyMallocAllocationForNativeType - START" << std::endl;
    size_t numOfDoublesOnTheHeap = 3;
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyMallocAllocationForNativeType - sizeof double is " << sizeof(double) << std::endl; 
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyMallocAllocationForNativeType - allocaitng " << sizeof(double) * numOfDoublesOnTheHeap << " bytes on the heap" << std::endl;
    double* arr = static_cast<double*>(malloc(sizeof(double) * numOfDoublesOnTheHeap));

    // NOT free-ing them on purpose !!
    // free(arr);
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyMallocAllocationForNativeType - END" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyNewAllocationForNativeSTLVectorType) 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForNativeSTLVectorType - START" << std::endl;
    std::vector<int> vecInt;
    vecInt.push_back(12);
    vecInt.push_back(15);
    vecInt.push_back(17);

    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForNativeSTLVectorType - END" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyNewAllocationForUserDefinedSTLVectorType) 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForUserDefinedSTLVectorType - START" << std::endl;
    std::vector<MyObject*> vecMyObj;
    vecMyObj.push_back(new MyObject(7,8));
    vecMyObj.push_back(new MyObject(9,10));

    size_t vecSize = vecMyObj.size();
    for (int i = 0; i < vecSize; ++i) {
        delete vecMyObj[i];
    }

    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyNewAllocationForUserDefinedSTLVectorType - END" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyInPlaceAllocationAndDeAllocationForUserDefinedType) 
{
     std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyInPlaceAllocationAndDeAllocationForUserDefinedType - START" << std::endl;
    void* p1 = malloc(sizeof(MyObject));
    MyObject *p2 = new (p1) MyObject(12,13);

    p2->~MyObject();
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyInPlaceAllocationAndDeAllocationForUserDefinedType - END" << std::endl;
}

TEST_F(MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest, verifyInPlaceAllocationForUserDefinedType) 
{
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyInPlaceAllocationForUserDefinedType - START" << std::endl;
    void* p1 = malloc(sizeof(MyObject));
    MyObject *p2 = new (p1) MyObject(12,13);

    // Dont delete the object on purpose !!
    //p2->~MyObject();
    std::cout << "MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest::verifyInPlaceAllocationForUserDefinedType - END" << std::endl;
}

这个类的头文件：

// memoryLeakDetectorPocTest.h
#include "gtest/gtest.h"
#include "memoryLeakDetectorBase.h"

// The fixture for testing class Foo.
class MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest : public MemoryLeakDetectorBase
{
protected:

    // You can do set-up work for each test here.
    MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest();

    // You can do clean-up work that doesn't throw exceptions here.
    virtual ~MemoryLeakDetectorPocTest();

    // Code here will be called immediately after the constructor (right
    // before each test).
    virtual void SetUp();

    // Code here will be called immediately after each test (right
    // before the destructor).
    virtual void TearDown();
};

Answer 4

通过添加有关分配的内存跟踪信息，您可以通过提供自己的new 、 delete 、 malloc和free函数实现来检测测试中的内存泄漏。