异步代码的单元测试

Question

I have got some code, which is using HttpWebRequest class's .BeginGetResponse() method and it is asynchronous. Also, I am using Microsoft's Unit Test App project for testing application.

The problem is that test framework does not waiting for end of running asynchronous code, so I can not check its result.

How should I test asynchronous code using Unit Test App project? I'm not using async/await modificators.

Answer 1

Update Answer
The original answer was quite an old one, before async and await were prevalent. I'd now recommend using them, by writing something like:

[TestMethod]
public async Task RunTest()
{
    var result = await doAsyncStuff();
    // Expectations
}

There's a good article that covers this in depth Async Programming : Unit Testing Asynchronous Code

Old Answer

I would tend to something simple like using a polling loop and checking a flag that would be set in the async code or you could use reset events. A simple example using threads:

[TestMethod]
public void RunTest()
{
    ManualResetEvent done = new ManualResetEvent(false);
    Thread thread = new Thread(delegate() {
        // Do some stuff
        done.Set();
    });
    thread.Start();

    done.WaitOne();
}

You'll need to think about exceptions and use a try/finally and report the errors to do this properly, but you get the idea. This method however might not suit if you're doing lots of async stuff over and over, unless you fancy pushing this into a reusable method.

Answer 2

You could also use async/await pattern (using the HttpWebRequest wrapper from the Microsoft.Bcl.Async nuget package ). This will also neatly handle any exceptions that occur in your background thread.

For example:

[TestMethod]
public void RunTest()
{
    bool asyncDone = false;

    // this is a dummy async task - replace it with any awaitable Task<T>
    var task = Task.Factory.StartNew(() => 
    {
        // throw here to simulate bad code
        // throw new Exception();

        // Do some stuff
        asyncDone = true;
    });

    // Use Task.Wait to pause the test thread while the background code runs.
    // Any exceptions in the task will be rethrown from here.
    task.Wait();

    // check our result was as expected
    Assert.AreEqual(true, asyncDone);
}

Answer 3

现在已经晚了，但我想这会更具可读性和真实性

await Task.Delay(TimeSpan.FromSeconds(5)); 

Answer 4

检查接受的答案 ，该答案使用Silverlight单元测试框架对异步代码进行单元测试。