使用fork / execvp和系统调用之间的区别

Question

What is the difference between using system() to execute a binary and using the combination of fork/execvp.

Is there any security/portablility/performance difference.

Answer 1

System also uses a fork / exec ... combination. If you do fork / exec yourself you can execute parallel to your running process, while system is blocking (includes the wait ). Also system executes the command not direct, but via a shell (which makes problems with setuid bit) and system blocks/ignores certain signals (SIGINT, SIGCHILD, SIGQUIT).

Answer 2

Yes, system() runs the command through a shell, while exec() runs the command directly. Of course, introducing a shell opens up for bugs and exploits.

Edit: of course, the man page provides more detail.

Answer 3

system() will fork() / exec() the shell, and then shell will fork() / exec() the program you want to launch.

So system() is twice as heavy as fork() / exec()

Answer 4

system() works on Windows but fork() doesn't.

Unless you use a compatibility layer such as Cygwin, but even then a fork can be very expensive.

Answer 5

还有popen（），它类似于system（），但允许读取子的输出并提供输入