已弃用的注册关键字C ++ 11的替换

Question

我已读（ 这里 ，例如），该register关键字将在C ++ 11这样弃用，是有一个相当于在标准的较新版本此存储类说明，或它由编译器照顾？

Answer 1

We can find the rationale for deprecating register in defect report 809: Deprecation of the register keyword which says ( emphasis mine ):

The register keyword serves very little function, offering no more than a hint that a note says is typically ignored . It should be deprecated in this version of the standard, freeing the reserved name up for use in a future standard, much like auto has been re-used this time around for being similarly useless.

The removal of register for C++17 was approved in the Lenexa meeting but it is still reserved for future use.

The register keyword was deprecated in the 2011 C++ standard, as its effect was already implicit in the language . It remains reserved for future use by the standard, and is time to remove its vestigial specification.

Because of the as-if rule the compiler only has to emulate the observable behavior of the program and therefore the optimizer can via the as-if rule choose to keep a variable in a register if it won't effect observable behavior and presumably will in most cases make better choices since it usually has more information.

For reference also see role of "register" C keyword? from the gcc mailing list, one of the replies in the thread says:

I don't think the "register" keyword ever affected register allocation in gcc. For that you have to go back to compilers of the 1970s.

The register keyword does still have a use, though, in a gcc extension: gcc uses it in combination with asm to implement register variables.

Answer 2

It was never a guarantee that the compiler would listen to you if you used the keyword (and in some cases, it was a guarantee it would ignore you, like if you took the address).

This hinting ability is now deprecated, and there is no replacement (that is standard. inline asm is not standard, but could be used).

Answer 3

假设编译器可以比程序员更好地将变量分配给寄存器，因此不推荐使用register ，新标准中没有其他等效关键字。

Answer 4

Just a note that using JetBrains ReShaper in Visual Studio 2015 , I was told register keyword is deprecated in C++11 and removed in C++17 and suggested me to replace it with auto keyword for this piece of code:

float constant = 1.0f / 478.01;
int centerX = (pointcloud.width >> 1);
int centerY = (pointcloud.height >> 1);
auto depth_idx = 0;
for (auto v = -centerY; v < centerY; ++v)
{
    for (auto u = -centerX; u < centerX; ++u, ++depth_idx)
    {
        pcl::PointXYZ& pt = pointcloud.points[depth_idx];
        pt.z = depth_data[depth_idx] * 0.001f;
        pt.x = static_cast<float> (u) * pt.z * constant;
        pt.y = static_cast<float> (v) * pt.z * constant;
    }
}