jar清单classpath和-classpath命令行选项如何组合

Question

If I have an executable jar X.jar, with a classpath defined in a manifest, and I want to include other jars on the classpath than these, will

java -classpath a.jar;b.jar;c.jar -jar X.jar

COMBINE these classpaths or OVERRIDE the manifest classpath in X.jar with the classpath specified on the command line.

(and if they will be combined, in what order will they be combined)?

Answer 1

They don't combine.

If you specify 'java -jar', the -classpath option is ignored, and the effective CLASSPATH comes from the manifest.

If you don't specify 'java -jar',the manifest Class-path is ignored.

This is all documented.