结合使用cookie和会话来保持用户登录是否是一个好主意

Question

I am looking at the possibilty to set up a option to keep users logged in. Now I understand a session could be used to allow a user to navigate around without re-entering login information on each page only until the browser is closed and the session is lost. A cookie would be stored client side and has a duration until it expires or the user deletes the cookie.

I was thinking that I could use a combination of both

1. Create a db table (id,user_id,cookie_token,is_active)

2. User logs in which creates a row in the db table connecting the user to the cookie_token which is stored on the client browser (system) as well.

   • Each time a token is created, check to see if the user the token is being created for has any active tokens in the system already and set those to inactive before a new one is created.
   • Only one token can be active per user

So every time the user visits the site, the system looks up that token and checks is_active fields, If the user_token is found and is_active = 1 or true, the user data is retrieved (id,name,etc) and this then creates the session and the session variables.

I am not able to find any questions or answers that use a combination of both so it could be that this is just overkill or a very bad idea, I just started to read up on sessions and cookies and have been trying to figure out a system that I could implement myself so would be nice to know if this is good or bad.

Answer 1

I can't reply as a comment anymore, because my reply would be too long... I've implemented something like follows. Unfortunately I can't remember it precisely, but it would give you a pretty good idea:

Visit before manual login:

• Start a session.
• At successful login, store a user identification into this session and store a token value into the dB and into the cookie.

Next time the browser visits the page:

• (re)Start the session.
• Check if a user identification is set in this session.
  • If so, auto-login the user which matches the identification.
  • If not (session expired due time restriction or browser close), check if a token value is stored in the cookie and if this value matches a token value stored in the dB.
    • If an (unexpired) match found, auto-login the user and remove old tokens.
    • If the user identification is invalid and the token value is invalid/expired:
      • logout the user (which contains all actions to go back to "public" mode like destroying the session, removing tokens, cookies, etc.).