[英]C# weak reference still valid after object GC?
I've got a quick code piece to test weak reference, I expect that after the object being GC, the weak reference should not longer return a object referenct. 我有一个快速的代码段可以测试弱引用,我希望在对象成为GC之后,弱引用应该不再返回对象引用。 But my test shows this is not expected: 但是我的测试表明这不是预期的:
class Person
{
private int mI = 3;
public int MI { get => mI; set => mI = value; }
}
class UseWeakReference
{
public static void Main(String[] args)
{
Person person = new Person();
WeakReference<Person> wr = new WeakReference<Person>(person);
wr.TryGetTarget(out Person p1);
Console.WriteLine(p1);
person = null;
wr.TryGetTarget(out Person p2);
Console.WriteLine(p2);
p2 = null;
System.GC.Collect();
Thread.Sleep(1000);
wr.TryGetTarget(out Person p3);
Console.WriteLine(p3); // I expected null here becaure person is collected.
}
}
It prints: 它打印:
MyApp1.Person
MyApp1.Person
MyApp1.Person // Why still valid?
Where did I get wrong? 我在哪里弄错了?
Thanks. 谢谢。
When you call TryGetTarget
on a weak reference, assuming that the referenced object has not already been collected, you get back a strong reference to that object. 当您在一个弱引用上调用TryGetTarget
时,假设尚未收集被引用的对象,您将获得对该对象的强引用。 You do this 3 times in your code: p1
, p2
and p3
are strong references to the object. 您在代码中执行了3次: p1
, p2
和p3
是对该对象的强引用。 When the garbage collector runs - automatically or in your case when you force garbage collection - those strong references will prevent the object being collected. 当垃圾收集器运行时-自动运行或在您强制垃圾收集时运行-那些强引用将阻止对象的收集。
Here's a version that works: 这是一个有效的版本:
void Main()
{
var person = new Person();
WeakReference<Person> weak = new WeakReference<Person>(person);
person = null;
for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++)
{
Console.WriteLine($"{i}\t{TestReference(weak)}");
Thread.Sleep(100);
}
GC.Collect();
Console.WriteLine(TestReference(weak));
}
class Person
{
private int mI = 3;
public int MI { get => mI; set => mI = value; }
}
bool TestReference(WeakReference<Person> weak)
{
if (weak.TryGetTarget(out Person p))
{
p = null;
return true;
}
return false;
}
Note that at no point are we keeping a strong reference to the object alive for more than a few cycles, and by the time the garbage collector runs there are no strong references to the object so the object is collected. 请注意,在任何情况下,我们始终都不会对对象保持强大的引用超过几个周期,并且在垃圾回收器运行时,没有针对该对象的强大引用,因此无法收集该对象。
Even in this code though if I comment out the p = null;
即使在这段代码中,即使我注释掉p = null;
line the garbage collector may not collect the object. 行中的垃圾收集器可能不会收集对象。 Try it and see. 试试看。
The moral of the story is: when you obtain a strong reference from a WeakReference<>
, always null the strong reference when you're done with it. 这个故事的寓意是:当您从WeakReference<>
获得强引用时,在完成该操作后, 始终将其WeakReference<>
空。
声明:本站的技术帖子网页,遵循CC BY-SA 4.0协议,如果您需要转载,请注明本站网址或者原文地址。任何问题请咨询:yoyou2525@163.com.