在 ApplicationUser 中保持用户锁定状态的最佳方法是什么？

Question

I want to save the user's lockout status in my ApplicationUser (inherited from IdentityUser) in Asp.Net Mvc (Core or NetFramework), so which implementation is better from the design perspective?

1. User with IsActive property and LockoutReason enum property, separately

class ApplicationUser: IdentityUser
{
    // ...
    public bool IsAcitve {get;  set;}
    public UserLockoutReason LockoutReason {get; set; }
}

enum UserLockoutReason 
{
    NotLocked,
    LockedByAdmin,
    MaximumWrongPasswordAttemptsReached,
    ...
}

2. User with ActiveStatus enum

class ApplicationUser: IdentityUser
{
    // ...
    public UserActiveStatus ActiveStatus {get; set; }
}

enum UserActiveStatus
{
    Active,
    LockedByAdmin,
    MaximumWrongPasswordAttemptsReached,        
    ...
}

ps: This design is going to be as an UserManagement's part to our IdentityProvider, so it's is so important to us to implement the best way we can

Answer 1

I would go in this direction:

class ApplicationUser: IdentityUser
{
    // ...
    public UserActiveStatus ActiveStatus {get; set; }
}

enum UserActiveStatus
{
    Active,
    LockedByAdmin,
    MaximumWrongPasswordAttemptsReached,        
    ...
}

Since the ActiveStatus is the final information that you will need for the user, there will be need to branch of user.IsActive in if-else statements, and then getting the LockoutReason in case it's locked account won't be neccesary