AWS 基础设施即代码的文档

Question

Recently, while trying to build a terraform IaC, I found that I couldn't get the API Gateway to route to the Lambda properly. It turned out that when using the console AWS automatically assigns the permissions the gateway needs for the Lambda, but with IaC in terraform this must be assigned explicitly.

The above is understandable but for a newbie, to both AWS and terraform, confusing.

Is there documentation which explains the required components within an infrastructure connection, such as that above?

I know of the AWS docs and the terraform docs are particularly well thought out but none of it actually explains (as far as I've seen) that a certain resource is required in any particular (however common or obscure) setup. Inferring these connections from general searching is not a great replacement.

Answer 1

I don't think that there is a documentation that lists "all of the required components" in one single page/area. But you can get different pieces of information from different docs, and as you mentioned AWS and Terraform do both a great job at this.

Talking about AWS, in the case of permissions in API gateway, I can think of two useful links (the 1st one is referenced from the 2nd one though):

• How API Gateway resource policies affect authorization workflow
• Control access for invoking an API

I agree in the fact that sometimes it's a lot of guesses to translate AWS into terraform if you don't really know what you are trying to achieve. Usually when I am blocked on something that "should theoritically work" in IaC vs AWS console, I step back from the problem and try to figure out what kind of components am I really trying to glue together in AWS world. Then usually things become more obvious.

Because in terraform it's really creating small independant pieces of infrastructure and make them work together. Comparing with other IaC, in my experience it's a lot more granular than CloudFormation for instance.

A personal practice that helps me figure out things faster is to read every single intro doc of the components I am working on in Terraform. For instance, if I am writing lambda in terraform IaC, I would quickly read all the lambda_xxxx_yyyy intro parts to get less stuck and react faster when something fails. It usually works for me.

Answer 2

I haven't see such a documentation, but I can share my work-around for similar cases.

You can make changes you need using AWS console - manually, using UI. Then you can define resources you just created in your TF files, defining only/required required set of properties, even random values will work. Then you import what you created manually into resources you defined.

By running terraform plan you will see the differences, that will allow you to adjust your TF files accordingly.

After few iterations you will replicate what you have just done in the UI using TF. As a final test you can manually revert your changes, run terraform apply and ensure that everything works as expected.