React ForwardRef：“ForwardedRef”类型上不存在属性“current”<htmlelement> '</htmlelement>

Question

I am trying to create a component that will track the vertical scroll. The catch is – the actual scroll container is not easily predictable (in this specific case it is neither window , document nor body – it is div#__next , due to CSS overflow rules).

I want to keep the component flexible and self-contained. So I've created a ref with DOM selector as an argument. I know it is far from idiomatic (to say the least), but it suprisingly seems to be working:

// Parent component
import { useRef } from "react"

const Article = (props) => {
  const scrollContainerRef = useRef<HTMLElement | null>(
    document.querySelector("#__next") // <-- the scroll container reference
  )

  return (
    <SomeContent>
      <ScrollToTop treshold={640} ref={scrollContainerRef} />
    </SomeContent>
)

// ScrollToTop
const ScrollToTop = forwardRef(
  ({ treshold }, ref) => {
    const [visible, setVisible] = useState(false)

    useEffect(() => {

      if (ref?.current) {
        ref.current.addEventListener("scroll", throttle(toggleVisible, 300))
        return () => {
          ref.current.removeEventListener("scroll", throttle(toggleVisible, 300))
        }
      }
    }, [])
// …

So what's the problem? the current one is Typescript . I've spent hours trying to get the types right, but to no avail. The parent component is red squigly lines free (unless I pass globalThis , which seems to work at least in CodeSandbox), but the ScrollToTop is compaining whenever I am accessing current property:

Property 'current' does not exist on type 'ForwardedRef<HTMLElement>'.

I've tried to use React.MutableRefObject<HTMLElement | null /* or other T's */> React.MutableRefObject<HTMLElement | null /* or other T's */> , both in parent and in child, but it didn't help.

Any ideas how to get the types to match? Or is this a silly idea from the beginning?

CodeSandbox demo

Answer 1

Refs might be objects with a .current property, but they might also be functions. So you can't assume that a forwarded ref has a .current property.

I think it's a mistake to use forwardRef at all here. The purpose of forwardRef is to allow a parent component to get access to an element in a child component. But instead, the parent is the one finding the element, and then you're passing it to the child for it to use. I would use a regular state and prop for that:

const Article = (props) => {
  const [scrollContainer, setScrollContainer] = useState<HTMLElement | null>(() => {
    return document.querySelector("#__next");
  });

  return (
    <SomeContent>
      <ScrollToTop treshold={640} scrollContainer={scrollContainer} />
    </SomeContent>
)

interface ScrollToTopProps {
  treshold: number;
  scrollContainer: HTMLElement | null;
}

const ScrollToTop = ({ treshold, scrollContainer }: ScrollToTopProps) => {
  const [visible, setVisible] = useState(false);

  useEffect(() => {
    if (scrollContainer) {
      const toggle = throttle(toggleVisible, 300);
      scrollContainer.addEventListener("scroll", toggle);
      return () => {
        scrollContainer.removeEventListener("scroll", toggle);
      }
    }
  }, [scrollContainer]);
  // ...
}