安全的客户端脚本

Question

I have got a particular requirement where some critical algorithms have to be handled in the client-side script and it got to be secured. Using javascript will just expose the algorithm. I am currently evaluating ways to secure the algorithm on the client script. Appreciate any suggestions and alternative approaches.

One option I am thinking about is to download a small applet to the local PC, get the calculations done in it and update the results back. Before deciding on this, I want to know if a client script itself can be made secure coz that would be much easier.

Thanks in advance!

Answer 1

You CANNOT secure anything on a client PC.

Everything you are doing client-side is crackable and spuffable.

That's the PC of the client. It will be doing anything the client has requested it to do.

Answer 2

Script is not secure, also what level of security do you need? If you download anything to the client the client will be able to look at the algorithim. Of course if you download a native dll, then decompiling it will be harder, the question is if this is good enough.

That an important thing most people miss when evaluating security nothing is trully 100% secure. Because your server admin could go in and steal the binaries off your server. And if your using third party hosting who knows who has access to the server.

The idea is to raise the bar. Do you want to prevent the average script kiddie? Obfuscate it, make it hard for them to understand the gain of understanding the algorithim might not justify the pain in trying to understand it.

The best that you can probally do is keep the algorithim on the server and expose it via a web service.

Answer 3

Everything that the end-user is controlling to 100% may be tampered with, and this is especially true with JavaScript that is so easily exposed.

You are going down the wrong path. You need to rethink your approach.

Answer 4

您可以构建包含关键算法的Web服务，并从javascript调用它。

Answer 5

Bottom line is, if someone wants your logic ... they will get it unless it is server-side and they never obtain it in any way.

What you want is a Javascript obfuscator

Answer 6

Nothing on the client side can be totally "secure".

Anything you make them download will have to be run on the client PC, and so can be analysed. If you have them download an applet or a native executable, it will still contain machine instructions that can be analysed at the very least to an assembly level.

Is there no way you can have the client upload the data to your server instead and perform the calculation on the server side?

Answer 7

It it's client-side, then it's not secure. Anything with critical security concerns should be done on the server.

Answer 8

NPAPI插件将在客户端执行，并使逆向工程变得更加困难......但当然一个坚定的黑客将能够通过...

Answer 9

Theoretically (and I mean this is a Comp.Sci. sense) this is possible. The cryptographical technique is known as "fully homomorphic encryption". For now, the method isn't practical yet. There are no compilers available that are able to transform your algorithm in its equivalent secure form.