STL basic_string长度为空字符

Question

Why is it that you can insert a '\\0' char in a std::basic_string and the .length() method is unaffected but if you call char_traits<char>::length(str.c_str()) you get the length of the string up until the first '\\0' character?

eg

string str("abcdefgh");
cout << str.length(); // 8
str[4] = '\0';
cout << str.length(); // 8
cout << char_traits<char>::length(str.c_str()); // 4

Answer 1

Great question!

The reason is that a C-style string is defined as a sequence of bytes that ends with a null byte. When you use .c_str() to get a C-style string out of a C++ std::string , then you're getting back the sequence the C++ string stores with a null byte after it. When you pass this into strlen , it will scan across the bytes until it hits a null byte, then report how many characters it found before that. If the string contains a null byte, then strlen will report a value that's smaller than the whole length of the string, since it will stop before hitting the real end of the string.

An important detail is that strlen and char_traits<char>::length are NOT the same function. However, the C++ ISO spec for char_traits<charT>::length (§21.1.1) says that char_traits<charT>::length(s) returns the smallest i such that char_traits<charT>::eq(s[i], charT()) is true. For char_traits<char> , the eq function just returns if the two characters are equal by doing a == comparison, and constructing a character by writing char() produces a null byte, and so this is equal to saying "where is the first null byte in the string?" It's essentially how strlen works, though the two are technically different functions.

A C++ std::string , however, it a more general notion of "an arbitrary sequence of characters." The particulars of its implementation are hidden from the outside world, though it's probably represented either by a start and stop pointer or by a pointer and a length. Because this representation does not depend on what characters are being stored, asking the std::string for its length tells you how many characters are there, regardless of what those characters actually are.

Hope this helps!