删除除一个以外的所有重复项

Question

We have a table business_users with a user_id and business_id and we have duplicates. How can I write a query that will delete all duplicates except for one?

Answer 1

Completely identical rows

If you want to avoid completely identical rows, as I understood your question at first, then you can select unique rows to a separate table and recreate the table data from that.

CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE tmp SELECT DISTINCT * FROM business_users;
DELETE FROM business_users;
INSERT INTO business_users SELECT * FROM tmp;
DROP TABLE tmp;

Be careful if there are any foreign key constraints referencing this table, though, as the temporary deletion of rows might lead to cascaded deletions elsewhere.

Introducing a unique constraint

If you only care about pairs of user_id and business_id , you probably want to avoid introducing duplicates in the future. You can move the existing data to a temporary table, add a constraint, and then move the table data back, ignoring duplicates.

CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE tmp SELECT * FROM business_users;
DELETE FROM business_users;
ALTER TABLE business_users ADD UNIQUE (user_id, business_id);
INSERT IGNORE INTO business_users SELECT * FROM tmp;
DROP TABLE tmp;

The above answer is based on this answer . The warning about foreign keys applies just as it did in the section above.

One-shot removal

If you only want to execute a single query, without modifying the table structure in any way, and you have a primary key id identifying each row, then you can try the following:

DELETE FROM business_users WHERE id NOT IN
    (SELECT MIN(id) FROM business_users GROUP BY user_id, business_id);

A similar idea was previously suggested by this answer .

If the above request fails, because you are not allowed to read and delete from a table in the same step, you can again use a temporary table:

CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE tmp
SELECT MIN(id) id FROM business_users GROUP BY user_id, business_id;
DELETE FROM business_users WHERE id NOT IN (SELECT id FROM tmp);
DROP TABLE tmp;

If you want to, you can still introduce a uniqueness constraint after cleaning the data in this fashion. To do so, execute the ALTER TABLE line from the previous section.

Answer 2

Since you have a primary key, you can use that to pick which rows to keep:

delete from business_users
where id not in (
    select id from (
        select min(id) as id -- Make a list of the primary keys to keep
        from business_users
        group by user_id, business_id -- Group by your duplicated row definition
    ) as a -- Derived table to force an implicit temp table
);

In this way, you won't need to create/drop temp tables and such (except the implicit one ).

You might want to put a unique constraint on user_id, business_id so you don't have to worry about this again.