在java中返回一个原子操作的int？

Question

// is this atomic? 
public int size() {
    return count;
}

Note that count can be changed by other methods in other threads.

I know integer reads and writes are atomic, but I am not sure about return.

What got me alarmed is that for some reason ArrayBlockingQueue locks it's size() method.

Answer 1

Reads and writes to primitive int are atomic as you already know. Returning is basically reading and placing in some other place in memory. Since reading is atomic, no race condition will occur. You either return previous or next value of int .

Using lock in ArrayBlockingQueue might be due to visibility reasons. count variable is not volatile so if the queue was modified in the meantime, without some sort of locking you are not guaranteed to see the most recent value of count . But since read and writes are atomic, at least you'll never see youngest 16 bits of old value and oldest 16 bits of new value.

Answer 2

Reading primitives ( except long and double) is atomic.

But suppose there is a synchronized method which is modifying value of the count ; in such case your read may or may not be atomic.

 synchronized void changeCount(){
     //modifying value of count
 }

So in that case you should also synchronized your read method or minimum declare count as volatile. This will ensure that read is also atomic and the correct and consistent value is returned