MySQL Match ...反对查询非常慢

Question

我在Propel ORM上运行的网站上工作，我有这个查询：

if(isset($args["QueryText"]) && $args["QueryText"] != "") {
  $query = $query
    ->withColumn("(MATCH (Request.Subject, Request.Detail) AGAINST ('" . $args["QueryText"] . "' IN BOOLEAN MODE) + MATCH (Response.Response) AGAINST ('" . $args["QueryText"] . "' IN BOOLEAN MODE))", "RequestRelevance")
    ->condition('cond1', "(MATCH (Request.Subject, Request.Detail) AGAINST ('" . $args["QueryText"] . "' IN BOOLEAN MODE) + MATCH (Response.Response) AGAINST ('" . $args["QueryText"] . "' IN BOOLEAN MODE)) > 0.2")
    ->condition('cond2', 'Request.Id = ?', $args["QueryText"])
    ->where(array('cond1', 'cond2'), 'or')
    ->orderBy("RequestRelevance", Criteria::DESC);
}

在SQL中转换为以下内容：

SELECT DISTINCT 
(MATCH (requests.subject, requests.detail) AGAINST ('46104' IN BOOLEAN MODE) + 
    MATCH (Response.response) AGAINST ('46104' IN BOOLEAN MODE)) 
  AS RequestRelevance, requests.requestID AS "Id", requests.subject AS "Subject", requests.detail AS "Detail", requests.created AS "CreatedDate", requests.lastresponsedate AS "LastResponseDate", SupportStatus.supportstatusID AS "SupportStatus.Id", SupportStatus.supportstatus AS "SupportStatus.Name", SupportStatus.isnew AS "SupportStatus.IsNew", SupportStatus.isclosed AS "SupportStatus.IsClosed", CustomerGroup.customergroupID AS "CustomerGroup.Id", CustomerGroup.customergroup AS "CustomerGroup.Name", Site.siteID AS "Site.Id", Site.site AS "Site.Name", InternalUser.userID AS "InternalUser.Id", InternalUser.username AS "InternalUser.Username", User.userID AS "User.Id", User.username AS "User.Username", Customer.customerID AS "Customer.Id", Customer.customer AS "Customer.Name", Customer.customergroupID AS "Customer.CustomerGroupId", Customer.rate AS "Customer.Rate" 
FROM requests 
  LEFT JOIN responses Response ON (requests.requestID=Response.requestID) 
  INNER JOIN supportstatus SupportStatus ON (requests.supportstatusID=SupportStatus.supportstatusID) 
  INNER JOIN customergroups CustomerGroup ON (requests.customergroupID=CustomerGroup.customergroupID)
  INNER JOIN customers Customer ON (requests.customerID=Customer.customerID) 
  INNER JOIN sites Site ON (requests.siteID=Site.siteID) 
  LEFT JOIN users InternalUser ON (requests.internaluserID=InternalUser.userID) 
  LEFT JOIN users User ON (requests.userID=User.userID)
WHERE ((MATCH (requests.subject, requests.detail) AGAINST ('46104' IN BOOLEAN MODE) + 
  MATCH (Response.response) AGAINST ('46104' IN BOOLEAN MODE)) > 0.2 OR requests.requestID = '46104') 
ORDER BY requests.created ASC,RequestRelevance DESC

使用Propel在网站上加载需要20秒，在运行SQL查询时需要7.020秒。

我尝试了以下一个：

SELECT DISTINCT 
  requests.requestID AS "Id", requests.subject AS "Subject", requests.detail AS "Detail", requests.created AS "CreatedDate", requests.lastresponsedate AS "LastResponseDate", SupportStatus.supportstatusID AS "SupportStatus.Id", SupportStatus.supportstatus AS "SupportStatus.Name", SupportStatus.isnew AS "SupportStatus.IsNew", SupportStatus.isclosed AS "SupportStatus.IsClosed", CustomerGroup.customergroupID AS "CustomerGroup.Id", CustomerGroup.customergroup AS "CustomerGroup.Name", Site.siteID AS "Site.Id", Site.site AS "Site.Name", InternalUser.userID AS "InternalUser.Id", InternalUser.username AS "InternalUser.Username", User.userID AS "User.Id", User.username AS "User.Username", Customer.customerID AS "Customer.Id", Customer.customer AS "Customer.Name", Customer.customergroupID AS "Customer.CustomerGroupId", Customer.rate AS "Customer.Rate" 
FROM requests 
  LEFT JOIN responses Response ON (requests.requestID=Response.requestID) 
  INNER JOIN supportstatus SupportStatus ON (requests.supportstatusID=SupportStatus.supportstatusID) 
  INNER JOIN customergroups CustomerGroup ON (requests.customergroupID=CustomerGroup.customergroupID)
  INNER JOIN customers Customer ON (requests.customerID=Customer.customerID) 
  INNER JOIN sites Site ON (requests.siteID=Site.siteID) 
  LEFT JOIN users InternalUser ON (requests.internaluserID=InternalUser.userID) 
  LEFT JOIN users User ON (requests.userID=User.userID) 
WHERE (requests.subject LIKE '%46104%' OR requests.detail LIKE '%46104%' OR  Response.response LIKE '%46104%' OR requests.requestID = '46104') 
ORDER BY requests.created

执行需要3.308秒。 删除OR Response.response LIKE '%46104%'会将时间减少到0.140秒。 响应表包含288317行，respond.responses列是带有FULLTEXT索引的TEXT（）列。

什么是减少此搜索执行时间的最佳方法？ 我尝试过使用这个https://dba.stackexchange.com/questions/15214/why-is-like-more-than-4x-faster-than-match-against-on-a-fulltext-index-in-mysq但是当我执行时回答：

SELECT responseID FROM
(
 SELECT * FROM responses
 WHERE requestID = 15000
 AND responseID != 84056
) A
WHERE MATCH(response) AGAINST('twisted');

我收到此错误：

Error Code: 1191. Can't find FULLTEXT index matching the column list

非常感谢帮助！

编辑1：

试过@Richard EB的查询：

ALTER TABLE responses ADD FULLTEXT(response)
288317 row(s) affected Records: 288317  Duplicates: 0  Warnings: 0  78.967 sec

然而：

SELECT responseID FROM (     SELECT * FROM responses     WHERE requestID = 15000     AND responseID != 84056 ) A WHERE MATCH(response) AGAINST('twisted') LIMIT 0, 2000 
Error Code: 1191. Can't find FULLTEXT index matching the column list    0.000 sec

删除DISTINCT会将执行时间减少到0.952秒，但它不会检索我需要的结果。

编辑2：

执行此查询：

SELECT DISTINCT 
responses.requestID AS "Id" FROM responses WHERE MATCH(response) AGAINST('twisted')

需要0.062秒。

执行此：

SELECT DISTINCT responses.requestID
  FROM responses 
WHERE (
  MATCH (Responses.response) AGAINST ('twisted' IN BOOLEAN MODE)
) 
ORDER BY responses.requestID ASC

只需0.046秒。 但是，从请求中选择并加入响应会降低查询速度。 我不确定这是否意味着必须完全重写整个查询以从响应和加入请求中进行选择？

编辑3：

以下是我在Requests和Responses表中的索引：

    # Table, Non_unique, Key_name, Seq_in_index, Column_name, Collation, Cardinality, Sub_part, Packed, Null, Index_type, Comment, Index_comment
    responses, 0, PRIMARY, 1, responseID, A, 288317, , , , BTREE, , 
    responses, 1, requestID, 1, requestID, A, 48052, , , YES, BTREE, , 
    responses, 1, response, 1, response, , 1, , , YES, FULLTEXT, , 
    responses, 1, response_2, 1, response, , 1, , , YES, FULLTEXT, , 
    responses, 1, response_3, 1, response, , 1, , , YES, FULLTEXT, , 

    # Table, Non_unique, Key_name, Seq_in_index, Column_name, Collation, Cardinality, Sub_part, Packed, Null, Index_type, Comment, Index_comment
    requests, 0, PRIMARY, 1, requestID, A, 46205, , , , BTREE, , 
    requests, 1, supportstatusID, 1, supportstatusID, A, 14, , , YES, BTREE, , 
    requests, 1, internaluserID, 1, internaluserID, A, 344, , , YES, BTREE, , 
    requests, 1, customergroupID, 1, customergroupID, A, 198, , , , BTREE, , 
    requests, 1, userID, 1, userID, A, 1848, , , YES, BTREE, , 
    requests, 1, siteID, 1, siteID, A, 381, , , YES, BTREE, , 
    requests, 1, request, 1, subject, , 1, , , YES, FULLTEXT, , 
    requests, 1, request, 2, detail, , 1, , , YES, FULLTEXT, , 
    requests, 1, request, 3, ponumber, , 1, , , YES, FULLTEXT, , 

Answer 1

LIKE搜索将遍历每条记录并执行非精确的字符串比较，这就是它如此慢的原因。

您粘贴的mysql错误表明MATCH子句中引用的列没有全文索引（或者它有，但它不是在MATCH子句中引用的）。

假设您正在使用MyISAM或拥有MySQL 5.6和InnoDB，请尝试：

ALTER TABLE responses ADD FULLTEXT(response);

编辑：答案（在评论中）：“如果MATCH语句中提到了两列，那么这两列上应该有一个全文索引，而不是每列上有两个全文索引”