奇怪的Haveing和Group By子句行为生成“'having'子句中的未知列”错误

Question

我在MySQL数据库中有两个表：

表格1

mysql> SELECT ID FROM table1;
+----+
| id |
+----+
|  6 |
+----+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

表2

mysql> SELECT * FROM table2;
+----+----------+------------------------+----------------------+
| id | placeId  | dictionaryId           | dictionaryCode       |
+----+----------+------------------------+----------------------+
| 54 |        6 |                      1 | MarketingTerritoryID |
| 53 |        6 |                      1 | PlaceTypeID          |
+----+----------+------------------------+----------------------+
2 rows in set (0.00 sec)

您能否解释一下以下sql查询为何起作用：

SELECT 
   table1.id
FROM table1
  LEFT JOIN table2 AS placeType
    ON table1.id = placeType.placeId
      AND placeType.dictionaryCode = 'PlaceTypeID'
  LEFT JOIN table2 AS region
    ON table1.id = region.placeId
      AND region.dictionaryCode  = 'MarketingTerritoryID'
GROUP BY region.dictionaryId
HAVING region.dictionaryId = MIN(1)

...和另一个

SELECT 
   table1.id
FROM table1
  LEFT JOIN table2 AS placeType
    ON table1.id = placeType.placeId
      AND placeType.dictionaryCode = 'PlaceTypeID'
  LEFT JOIN table2 AS region
    ON table1.id = region.placeId
      AND region.dictionaryCode  = 'MarketingTerritoryID'
GROUP BY region.dictionaryId, placeType.dictionaryId
HAVING region.dictionaryId = MIN(1)

返回sql错误： *Unknown column 'region.dictionaryId' in 'having clause'*

请注意，这两个查询之间的区别仅在于group子句：第二个查询也按placeType.dictionaryId分组

这是来自sqlfiddle的代码：

1. 首先查询http://sqlfiddle.com/#!9/46a85/7
2. 第二个查询http://sqlfiddle.com/#!9/46a85/8

Answer 1

我已将错误报告给mysql团队。 这是链接： https : //bugs.mysql.com/bug.php?id=82317

目前它已验证状态。 让我们看看他们会回答什么。