使用FlexibleContexts和FlexibleInstances有哪些陷阱？

Question

Since these flexible contexts and instances aren't available in the Haskell standard, I assume there are potential problems when using them. What are they? Can they lead to some ambiguity, undecidability, overlapping instances, etc.?

There is a similar question that asks only about FlexibleInstances , not FlexibleContexts , but the answer only says "that it's safe to use them".

Answer 1

I once stumbled upon the following. Answering this question , I first tried this code:

{-# LANGUAGE MultiParamTypeClasses #-}
{-# LANGUAGE FunctionalDependencies #-}

class (Eq a, Show a) => Genome a where
    crossover       :: (Fractional b) => b -> a -> a -> IO (a, a)
    mutate          :: (Fractional b) => b -> a -> IO a
    develop         :: (Phenotype b a)  => a -> b

class (Eq a, Show a) => Phenotype a b | a -> b where
    --  In case of Coevolution where each phenotype needs to be compared to 
    --  every other in the population
    fitness         :: [a] -> a -> Int 
    genome          :: (Genome b) => a -> b    -- here, the problem

breed parents cross mute = do
    children <- mapM (\ (dad, mom) -> crossover cross (genome dad) (genome mom)) 
                     parents
    let ch1 = map fst children ++ map snd children
    mutated <- mapM (mutate mute) ch1
    return $ map develop mutated

And got a compilation error and a suggestion by GHCi to add the FlexibleContexts option. When I did, it compiled OK. But this was actually not a right thing to do, as the constraint declaration introduced new scope for type variables, and b in genome 's type signature became completely unrelated to the one in the type class; yet FlexibleContexts provided a cover for this.

With the constraint specified properly at the type class level,

class (Eq a, Show a, Genome b) => Phenotype a b | a -> b where
    --  In case of Coevolution where each phenotype needs to be compared to 
    --  every other in the population
    fitness         :: [a] -> a -> Int 
    genome          :: a -> b

it passed compilation without requiring the FlexibleContexts option.