为什么在 Bash 中使用未设置的变量作为数组索引返回元素 0？

Question

Why is an empty key in a bash array always the zero key element?

Try

empty_key=

h[0]=0
h[1]=1
h[2]=2

echo ${h[$empty_key]}

Result

0

Could you please explain, why this behavior is correct?

In my understanding it should not be different to

not_existing_key=5 
echo ${h[$not_existing_key]}

where the result is just empty.

This is important to understand, if one uses the result for a loop, like in

for element in ${h[$key]};do
  ...
done

where the empty_key leads to a cycle, but NOT the not_existing_key.

To avoid this behavior it is obviously not to start an array with index 0

OR

replace an empty key by any key value not assigned (what seems to be boring).

Again my question: why is this behavior correct?

EDIT: My question should be understood as why is this behavior the prefered one in the bash world and not an empty result as with a non-existing key value?

Answer 1

When accessing an array element, [] constitutes an arithmetic context. This has a few consequences:

• no need for $ to dereference variables:

   $ arr=(abc) $ idx=1 $ echo ${arr[idx]} b

• arithmetic operations are evaluated:

   $ echo ${arr[idx+idx]} c

• variable names are dereferenced in "chains" ( evaluated as an arithmetic expression in the manual):

   $ idx=2 $ idxref=idx $ echo ${arr[idxref]} c

• names of null or unset variables are evaluated to 0 when used without parameter expansion syntax:

   $ notset= $ echo ${arr[notset]} a

• and finally (your question), a null value evaluates to 0 :

   $ notset= $ echo {$arr[$notset]} a

---

Manual quotes:

• Arrays :

  Indexed arrays are referenced using integers (including arithmetic expressions (see Shell Arithmetic )) [...]

• Shell Arithmetic :

  Shell variables are allowed as operands; parameter expansion is performed before the expression is evaluated. Within an expression, shell variables may also be referenced by name without using the parameter expansion syntax. A shell variable that is null or unset evaluates to 0 when referenced by name without using the parameter expansion syntax. [...] A null value evaluates to 0.