React hooks 性能和最佳实践

Question

In my React application I have the next situation. On each page I have to create this logic:

const user = useUser();
const message = user.auth ? 'Welcome' : 'You are not allowed'
    

<Button>{message}</Button>

I have to add this logic on 10 pages. I know that my question is more theoretical, but what is better in my case:

1. To add this logic on each page; or

2. To create a custom hook like useButtonMessage() which will look like this:

    export const useButtonMessage = () => { const user = useUser(); const message = user.auth ? 'Welcome' : 'You are not allowed' return message; }

Won't the hook be redundant if it keeps only 3 lines of code?

Answer 1

Personally, I like to create hooks with all relative things of a particular topic (instead of just one constant like message ). For example:

 export const useAuth = () => {
   const user = useUser()

   const isLoggedIn = user.auth
   const welcomeMessage = isLoggedIn ? 'Welcome' : 'You are not allowed'

   /*
     add selectors, functions to dispatch actions, 
     or other util contants such as welcomeMessage
   */

   return {
     isLoggedIn, // use this constant across your app to check if the user is logged in
     user, // use this across your app to obtain the user
     welcomeMessage,
   };
 }

Answer 2

I wouldn't create a hook for that but rather create a messages file where all the messages of the app will be stored

And then you can add conditional properties fe

export const messages = 
{
 userAllowed: (authenticated: boolean) => authenticated ? 'welcome' : 'you are not allowed'
}

You can even take it a step further:

export const messages =
{
 Welcome: 'welcome',
 NotAllowed: 'you are not allowed',
 userAllowed: function(authenticated: boolean) { 
  return authenticated ? this.Welcome : this.NotAllowed
 },
}