Apple 音频框架之间有什么区别？

Question

In the documentation I see several Apple frameworks for audio. All of them seem to be targeted at playing and recording audio. So I wonder what the big differences are between these?

• Audio Toolbox
• Audio Unit
• AV Foundation
• Core Audio

Did I miss a guide that gives a good overview of all these?

Answer 1

Core Audio is the lowest-level of all the frameworks and also the oldest.

Audio Toolbox is just above Core Audio and provides many different APIs that make it easier to deal with sound but still gives you a lot of control. There's ExtAudioFile, AudioConverter, and several other useful APIs.

Audio Unit is a framework for working with audio processing chains for both sampled audio data and MIDI. It's where the mixer and the various filters and effects such as reverb live.

AV Foundation is a new and fairly high-level API for recording and playing audio on the iPhone OS. All of them are available on both OS X and iOS, though AV Foundation requires OS X 10.8+.

Answer 2

I made a brief graphical overview of Core Audio and the its (containing) frameworks:

The framework closest to the hardware is Audio Unit . Based on that there is OpenAL and AudioToolbox with AudioQueue . On top you can find the Media Player and AVFoundation (Audio & Video) frameworks.

Now it depends on what you want to do: just a small recording, use AVFoundation , which is the most easiest one to use. (Media Player has no options for recording, it is - as the name says - just a media player.)

Do you want to do serious real time signal processing? Use Audio Unit. But believe me, this is hardest way. :-)

With iOS 8.0 Apple introduced AVAudioEngine , an Objective-C/Swift based audio graph system in AV Foundation. This encapsulate some dirty C-stuff from Audio Units. Due to the complexity of Audio Unit it is maybe worth a look.

Further readings in the Apple Documentation:

• Core Audio Overview: Introduction
• Multimedia Programming Guide
• Audio & Video Starting Point

Answer 3

Core Audio is not actually a framework, but an infrastructure that contains many different frameworks. Any audio that comes out of you iOS speaker is, in fact, managed by Core Audio.

The lowest-level in Core Audio that you can get is by using Audio Units, which you can work with by using the AudioToolbox and the AudioUnit frameworks.

The AudioToolbox framework also provides a bit higher level abstractions to deal with playing/recording of audio using AudioQueues, or managing various audio formats by using various Converter and File Services.

Finally, AV Foundation provides high level access to playing one specific file, and MediaPlayer gives you access (and playback) to your iPod library.

Answer 4

该站点对不同 API 的核心功能进行了简短而出色的概述： http : //cocoawithlove.com/2011/03/history-of-ios-media-apis-iphone-os-20.html

Answer 5

在这里您可以找到所有 iOS 和 OSX 音频框架的概述： https : //developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/MusicAudio/Conceptual/CoreAudioOverview/WhatsinCoreAudio/WhatsinCoreAudio.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/ TP40003577-CH4-SW4