这是什么意思：警告：从'void（ClassName :: *）（）'转换为'void（*）（）'

Question

I have a member function in a class that has a callback, but the callback isn't strictly neccessary, so it has a default callback, which is empty. It seems to work fine, but I get an annoying warning:

warning: converting from ‘void (ClassName::*)()’ to ‘void (*)()’

I'm trying to figure out what it means and how to turn it off (or fix it if I really am doing something wrong). Here's some simple code:

class ClassName{
public:
    void doSomething(void (*callbackFunction)() = (void(*)()) &ClassName::doNothing){
        callbackFunction();
    }
    void doNothing(){}
};

int main(){
    ClassName x;
    x.doSomething();
    return 0;
}

Note: If I do this (without explicitly casting it as a void(*)() ):

void doSomething(void (*callbackFunction)() = &ClassName::doNothing)

I get this:

main.cpp:3: error: default argument for parameter of type ‘void (*)()’ has type ‘void (ClassName::*)()’

Answer 1

The issue is that you're passing a pointer to an instance method rather than a static method. If you make doNothing a static method (which means no implicit instance argument), the warning goes away.

Specifically,

 warning: converting from 'void (ClassName::*)()' to 'void (*)()' 

exactly is saying that it's converting from a member function of class ClassName, to a non-member function.

See also the C++ FAQ Lite entry about pointers to member functions and pointers to functions .

Answer 2

Free function pointer is not the same as class member function pointer, which requires an instance of the class at call site. Though a static member function will do.