Proper way of testing ASP.NET Core IMemoryCache

Question

I'm writing a simple test case that tests that my controller calls the cache before calling my service. I'm using xUnit and Moq for the task.

I'm facing an issue because GetOrCreateAsync<T> is an extension method, and those can't be mocked by the framework. I relied on internal details to figure out I can mock TryGetValue instead and get away with my test (see https://github.com/aspnet/Caching/blob/c432e5827e4505c05ac7ad8ef1e3bc6bf784520b/src/Microsoft.Extensions.Caching.Abstractions/MemoryCacheExtensions.cs#L116 )

[Theory, AutoDataMoq]
public async Task GivenPopulatedCacheDoesntCallService(
    Mock<IMemoryCache> cache,
    SearchRequestViewModel input,
    MyViewModel expected)
{
    object expectedOut = expected;
    cache
        .Setup(s => s.TryGetValue(input.Serialized(), out expectedOut))
        .Returns(true);
    var sut = new MyController(cache.Object, Mock.Of<ISearchService>());
    var actual = await sut.Search(input);
    Assert.Same(expected, actual);
}

I can't sleep with the fact that I'm peeking into the MemoryCache implementation details and it can change at any point.

For reference, this is the SUT code:

public async Task<MyViewModel> Search(SearchRequestViewModel request)
{
    return await cache.GetOrCreateAsync(request.Serialized(), (e) => search.FindAsync(request));
}

Would you recommend testing any differently?

Answer 1

To be honest I would recommend not to test this interaction at all.

I would approach this test case a bit differently: what you really care about is that once your controller retrieved data from your ISearchService it shouldn't request the data again and should return the result from the previous call.

The fact that an IMemoryCache is used behind the scenes is just an implementation detail. I wouldn't even bother setting up a test double for it, I would just use an instance of the Microsoft.Extensions.Caching.Memory.MemoryCache object.

My new test would look something like this:

[Theory]
public async Task GivenResultAlreadyRetrieved_ShouldNotCallServiceAgain()
{
    // Arrange
    var expected = new MyViewModel();

    var cache = new MemoryCache(new MemoryCacheOptions());
    var searchService = new Mock<ISearchService>();

    var input = new SearchRequestViewModel();

    searchService
        .SetupSequence(s => s.FindAsync(It.IsAny<SearchRequestViewModel>()))
        .Returns(Task.FromResult(expected))
        .Returns(Task.FromResult(new MyViewModel()));

    var sut = new MyController(cache, searchService.Object);

    // Act
    var resultFromFirstCall = await sut.Search(input);
    var resultFromSecondCall = await sut.Search(input);

    // Assert
    Assert.Same(expected, resultFromFirstCall);
    Assert.Same(expected, resultFromSecondCall);
}