简体   繁体   中英

Is there a better Alloy model of a tree?

I created a model of a tree. See below. Is there a better model? By "better" I mean simpler.

sig Node {
    tree: set Node
}

one sig root extends Node {}

fact {
    // No node above root (no node maps to root)
    no tree.root
    // Can reach all nodes from root                
    all n: Node - root | n in root.^tree
    // No node maps to itself (irreflexive) 
    no iden & tree
    // No cycles                    
    no n: Node | Node in n.^tree
    // All nodes are distinct (injective)           
    tree.~tree in iden
}

What's not simple about this? You could simplify the constraints:

sig Node {
    tree: set Node
}

one sig root extends Node {}

pred CostelloTree {
    // No node above root (no node maps to root)
    no tree.root
    // Can reach all nodes from root                
    all n: Node - root | n in root.^tree
    // No node maps to itself (irreflexive) 
    no iden & tree
    // No cycles                    
    no n: Node | Node in n.^tree
    // All nodes are distinct (injective)           
    tree.~tree in iden
}

pred DJTree {
    Node in root.*tree // all reachable
    no iden & ^tree // no cycles
    tree in Node lone -> Node // at most one parent
    }

check {CostelloTree iff DJTree}

The technical post webpages of this site follow the CC BY-SA 4.0 protocol. If you need to reprint, please indicate the site URL or the original address.Any question please contact:yoyou2525@163.com.

 
粤ICP备18138465号  © 2020-2024 STACKOOM.COM