Using .bind (mootools) with onClick event

Question

I have the code (inside one object) onclick: this._addX.bind(this) and then inside another object onclick: this._addY.bind(this)

Now, _addX() and _addY are nearly identical, except they both end up calling (on the click event) a function with different argument values, say _addX calls foo('x') and _addY calls foo('y'). So I tried:

onclick: this._add.bind(this,'x') and onclick: this._add.bind(this,'y') in the two objects. And of course I changed _add to accept an argument.

At runtime, when _add is called, it does not see any incoming arguments! I have fumbled around with different syntaxes but nothing works. Any ideas? The original syntax works fine (no arguments) but forces me to duplicate a large function with only one line different, which pains me. Thanks in advance.

_add: function(which) {
    var me = this;
    var checkFull = function(abk) {
        if (abk.isFull) {
            alert("full");
        } else {
        alert(which);  // which is always undefined here!
        }
    };
    getAddressBook(checkFull); //checkFull is a fn called by getAddressBook
},

Answer 1

this works and it keeps the scope within an element click event with the scope set to the class and not the element--there is no point in passing scope to the add method, it already has that:

var foo = new Class({
    Implements: [Options],
    add: function(what) {
        alert(what);
    },
    initialize: function(options) {
        this.setOptions(options);

        this.options.element.addEvents({
            click: function() {
                this.add(this.options.what);
            }.bind(this)
        });
    }
});

window.addEvent("domready", function() {
    new foo({
        element: $("foo"),
        what: "nothin'"
    });
});

just make an element with id=foo and click it to test (alerts nothin'). if your onclick is a function / event handler within your class as opposed to a normal element click event, then things are going to differ slightly - post a working skeleton of your work on http://mootools.net/shell/

Answer 2

If you read my previous answer, disregard it. The MooTools .bind method supports passing parameters. So something else isn't working as you expect:

onclick: this._add.bind(this, 'y');

Here is a simple setup on JSBin to show how bind truly does pass parameters.

Answer 3

The only purpose of bind is to "tell" the JS what object you mean when you say this . ie you pass as a parameter to bind an instance of the object you wish the this key word will refer to inside the function you used the bind on.