Is hibernate search remote indexing possible?

Question

We are migrating a whole application originally developed in Oracle Forms a few years back, to a Java (7) web based application with Hibernate (4.2.7.Final) and Hibernate Search (4.1.1.Final).

One of the requirements is: as users are using the new migrated version, they able to use the Oracle Forms version - so Hibernate Search indexes will be out of sync. Is it feasable to implement a servlet so that some PL-SQL accesses some link that updates the local indexes in the application server (AS)?

I thought of implementing a some sort clustering mechanism for hibernate, but as I read through the documentation I realised that as clustering may be a good option for scalabillity and performance, for maintaining legacy data in sync may be a bit overkill.

Does anyone have any idea of how to implement a service, accessible via servlet, to update local AS indexes in a given model entity with a given ID?

Answer 1

I don't know what exactly you mean by the clustering part, but anyways:

It seems like you are facing a similar problem like me. I am currently in the works of creating a Hibernate-Search adaption for JPA providers (that are not Hibernate-ORM, meaning EclipseLink, TopLink, etc.) and I am working on an automatic reindexing feature at the moment. Since JPA doesn't have a event system suitable for reindexation with Hibernate-Search I came up with the idea to use triggers on a database level to keep track of everything.

For a basic OneToOne relationship it's pretty straight forward and for other things like relation-tables or anything that is not stored in the main table of an entity it gets a bit trickier, but once you got a system for OneToOne relationships it's not that hard to get to that next step. Okay, Let's start:

Imagine two Entities: Place and Sorcerer in the Lord of the rings universe. In order to keep things simple let's just say they are in a (quite restrictive :D) 1:1 relationship with each other. Normally you end up with 2 tables named SORCERER and PLACE.

Now you have to create 3 triggers (one for CREATE, one for DELETE and one for UPDATE) on each Table (SORCERER and PLACE) that store information about what entity (only the id, for mapping tables there are always multiple ids) has changed and how (CREATE, UPDATE, DELETE) into special UPDATE tables. Let's call these PLACE_UPDATES and SORCERER_UPDATES.

In addition to the ID of the original Object that has changed and the event-type these will need an ID field that is needed to be UNIQUE among all UPDATE tables. This is needed because if you want to feed information from the Update tables to the Hibernate-Search index you have to make sure the events are in the right order or you will break your index. How such an UNIQUE ID can be created on your database should be easy to find on the internet/stackoverflow.

Okay. Now that you have set up the triggers correctly you will just have to find a way to access all the UPDATES tables in a feasible fashion (I do this via querying from multiple tables at once and sorting each query by our UNIQUE id field and then just comparing the first result of each query with the others) and then update my index.

This can be a bit tricky and you have to find the correct ways of dealing with the specific update event but it can be done (that's what I am currently working on).

If you're interested in that part, you can find it here:

https://github.com/Hotware/Hibernate-Search-JPA/blob/master/hibernate-search-db/src/main/java/com/github/hotware/hsearch/db/events/IndexUpdater.java

The link to the whole project is:

https://github.com/Hotware/Hibernate-Search-JPA/

This uses Hibernate-Search 5.0.0.

I hope this was of help (at least a little bit).

And about your remote indexing problem:

The update tables can easily be used as some kind of dump for events until you send them to the remote machine that is to be updated.