FromBluetoothAddressAsync never returns on Windows 10 Creators Update in WPF Application

Question

I upgraded to Windows 10, version 1703 build 15063 (Creators Update) official release. When I run the following code in a WPF desktop application, BluetoothLEDevice.FromBluetoothAddressAsync never returns.

This code worked on fine before my Windows 10 update (ie the previous 1607 build 14393). This code also works fine if it is running as a UWP in the new Win 10 1703.

BluetoothLEAdvertisementWatcher BleWatcher = null;

private void Button_Click(object sender, RoutedEventArgs e)
{
     BleWatcher = new BluetoothLEAdvertisementWatcher
     {
          ScanningMode = BluetoothLEScanningMode.Active
     };
     BleWatcher.Received += Watcher_Received;
     BleWatcher.Start();
}

private async void Watcher_Received(BluetoothLEAdvertisementWatcher sender, 
                                    BluetoothLEAdvertisementReceivedEventArgs args)
{
         var device = await BluetoothLEDevice.FromBluetoothAddressAsync(args.BluetoothAddress);
         // never continues beyond this point above with my BTLE devices that previously worked 
}

I followed the instructions here https://stackoverflow.com/a/37335251/3187714 to setup my WPF desktop app to use the UWP APIs.

The problem is even worse because my existing WPF application will be broken when customers start upgrading to Win 10 1703 because my existing exe no longer works.

Is anyone else experiencing this problem with the Windows 10 1703 update in a (Non UWP) desktop exe?

After further experiments, I did find if I added the optional BluetoothAddressType.Public 2nd argument to the FromBluetoothAddressAsync call, the function returned, but the device returned was null.

var device = await BluetoothLEDevice.FromBluetoothAddressAsync(args.BluetoothAddress, BluetoothAddressType.Public);

Answer 1

It looks like there's a bug in the Security functions around the Bluetooth APIs in 15063 that's causing this (I'm seeing the same thing). Check out this thread:

https://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/58da3fdb-a0e1-4161-8af3-778b6839f4e1/bluetooth-bluetoothledevicefromidasync-does-not-complete-on-10015063?forum=wdk#ef927009-676c-47bb-8201-8a80d2323a7f

tl;dr For C++ applications, they provide a CoInitializeSecurity function to call. For everyone else, it looks like they're recommending creating an AppId in the registry, since P/Invoke isn't much fun.

Weirdly enough, things are working fine for me at the moment through noble-uwp, which uses C++ bindings to UWP functions for access via node.js. It's only via C# that I'm having issues, and things fail at different points depending on whether I'm in a UWP or WPF/Console/Desktop application.

After adding the AppId to the registry as outlined in the forum post, things worked for me again.

Answer 2

Interestingly, it does work on desktop applications using cppwinrt:

Advertisement::BluetoothLEAdvertisementWatcher watcher;

void Start() {
    watcher.ScanningMode(Advertisement::BluetoothLEScanningMode::Active);
    Windows::Foundation::TimeSpan timeout = std::chrono::seconds(2);
    watcher.SignalStrengthFilter().OutOfRangeTimeout(timeout);
    watcher.SignalStrengthFilter().OutOfRangeThresholdInDBm(-90);

    watcher.Received([&](Advertisement::BluetoothLEAdvertisementWatcher watcher, Advertisement::BluetoothLEAdvertisementReceivedEventArgs eventArgs) {
        connect(eventArgs.BluetoothAddress());
    });
    watcher.Start();
}

Windows::Foundation::IAsyncAction connect(uint64_t uuid) {
    co_await resume_background();
    BluetoothLEDevice device = co_await BluetoothLEDevice::FromBluetoothAddressAsync(uuid);
    GenericAttributeProfile::GattDeviceServicesResult gatt = co_await device.GetGattServicesForUuidAsync(myServiceUUID);
    // works fine!
}

However, notifications for GATT characteristics don't work for me after that. I have filed a bug report with the cppwinrt project, but the devs don't seem to be particularly inclined to look into it.

I have no idea what that API is doing differently than the desktop C# version.

Answer 3

If you wish to use the CoInitializeSecurity solution in VB, here is a pinvoke solution. Remember to unpair/repair all your BLE devices!

Note that is must be the fist thing executed in your code. Note that this is NOT AT ALL secure.

Public Enum RpcAuthnLevel
    Default1 = 0
    None = 1
    Connect = 2
    Call1 = 3
    Pkt = 4
    PktIntegrity = 5
    PktPrivacy = 6
End Enum

Public Enum RpcImpLevel
    Default1 = 0
    Anonymous = 1
    Identify = 2
    Impersonate = 3
    Delegate1 = 4
End Enum

Public Enum EoAuthnCap
    None = &H0
    MutualAuth = &H1
    StaticCloaking = &H20
    DynamicCloaking = &H40
    AnyAuthority = &H80
    MakeFullSIC = &H100
    Default1 = &H800
    SecureRefs = &H2
    AccessControl = &H4
    AppID = &H8
    Dynamic = &H10
    RequireFullSIC = &H200
    AutoImpersonate = &H400
    NoCustomMarshal = &H2000
    DisableAAA = &H1000
End Enum

Declare Function CoInitializeSecurity Lib "ole32.dll" (pVoid As IntPtr, cAuthSvc As Integer, asAuthSvc As IntPtr, pReserved1 As IntPtr, dwAuthnLevel As Integer, dwImpLevel As Integer, pAuthList As IntPtr, dwCapabilities As Integer, pReserved3 As IntPtr) As Integer

Private Sub Form1_Load(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles MyBase.Load
    CoInitializeSecurity(IntPtr.Zero, -1, IntPtr.Zero, IntPtr.Zero, RpcAuthnLevel.Default1, RpcImpLevel.Identify, IntPtr.Zero, EoAuthnCap.None, IntPtr.Zero)
    'Other code
End Sub