What do we need std::as_const() for?

Question

C++11 has given us std::add_const ; with C++17, we have a new structure - std::as_const() . The former just tacks a const before the type you provide it with. The second one is a proper (template of a) function, not type trait, which seems to do the same - except for when the type is an rvalue-reference, in which case it cannot be used.

I don't quite understand the motivation for providing std::as_const() . Why do we need it in addition to std::add_const ?

Answer 1

"Need" is a strong word... std::as_const exists because it's useful, not strictly necessary. Since it's a function rather than a trait, we can use it to "add const" to actual values rather than to types .

More specifically: Suppose I have some variable my_value and I want to treat it as a const , but not copy it. Before C++17 I would need to write:

static_cast<const MyType&>(my_value)

and if I don't want to specify the type explicitly, it would be:

static_cast<std::add_const_t<std::remove_reference_t<decltype(my_value)>> &>(my_value)

or if you want to get down and dirty, and use C-style casting:

(const decltype(my_value) &) (&my_value)

all of which are annoying and verbose.

Instead of these, with C++17 now write std::as_const(my_value) and that's all there is to it.

Notes:

• This function is disabled for rvalue references even though it works just fine for them. The reason is to help you avoid inadvertantly keeping a reference to a temporary past its destruction. As @NicolBolas explains, if you write something like:

   for(auto &x : std::as_const(returns_container())) { /* do stuff with x */ }

  then the returned container's lifetime ends before the first iteration of the loop. Very easy to miss!

• For additional (?) information, consult the official proposition of this utility function: P007R1 , by Adam David Alan Martin and Alisdair Meredith.

Answer 2

You may want to overload const, no-const and force one of the overloads:

template<class T> [[nodiscard]]
T twice(T const& t){return t + t;}

template<class T>
void twice(T& t){t += t;}

You can protect the input by adding const and use the non-modifying overload.

double t = 5.;
twice(t); // t == 10

double const u = 5.;
double ux2 = twice(u); // ux2 == 10, u == 5.;

double v = 5.;
double vx2 = twice(std::as_const(v)); // vx2 == 10., v==5. It saves you from
                                      // creating a const-reference
                                      // `double const& ucr = u;` just to pass
                                      // to the function.

I am not saying it is a good design, it is just to illustrate the point. It is a matter of time to find a more useful case.

---

A better name for std::as_const could have been std::protect IMO.