Blank nodes generating when adding object properties to the ontology

Question

I have an ontology in Protege.

When I add an object property like X worksFor Y , and then load the rdf to graphdb, it generates 3 triples with subject = blank node , property = owl:someValuesFrom, owl:onProperty, owl:rdfType , and then it adds a triple that states X rdf:subClassOf Y .

Is this correct?

What is the logic behind this?

---

Here is an example of what I'm doing:

This is the ontology in Protege. I made a small version that addresses this specific issue. I save it as rdf and then load it in GraphDb

And here is what I get in GraphDb after loading the rdf from the ontology.

I hope this helps to better understand the question.

Answer 1

The query output that you obtain is perfectly meaningful.

By stating that personaCliente (subject) is a SubClass Of (predicate) worksFor some empresaCliente (object), you're saying that if p is a client person then it must work for some client company. Note that the object is not a simple super-class, but a complex class expressed by a property restriction .

In other words, you're stating that every client person p works for some blank node _ , such that _ is a client company. If you know description logics , read this as persona ⊑ ∃worksFor.empresaCliente .

Now, by querying ?s?p?o , you're searching for all the possible triples of your ontology.

Let's focus on the following subset of results:

row  s                p                   o
1    _:node31         owl:someValuesFrom  :empresaCliente
2    _:node31         owl:onProperty      :worksFor
3    _:node31         rdf:type            owl:Restriction
9    :personaCliente  rdfs:subClassOf     _:node31

This bunch of triples means the same as above: every personaCliente is a subClassOf a certain blank node [9], such that this blank node is a subclassOf owl:Restriction (which is a particular OWL class) [3]. This restriction involves property worksFor [2] and states that its range, in this particular case, must be empresaCliente [1].

Further reading:

• https://www.w3.org/TR/owl2-syntax/#Object_Property_Restrictions
• https://www.cs.vu.nl/~guus/public/owl-restrictions/