SafeFileHandle in DLL import

Question

It's the first time I need to use P/Invoke to interact with device driver. In DeviceIoControl function I use SafeFileHandle for handle to the device and pinvoke.net says:

If you use a SafeFileHandle, do not call CloseHandle as the CLR will close it for you.

But in C# Cookbook I found this kind signature of CloseHandle:

[DllImport("kernel32.dll", SetLastError = true)]
public static extern bool CloseHandle(SafeFileHandle hObject);

What's the truth?

Answer 1

SafeFileHandle internally calls CloseHandle in its ReleaseHandle method, and is designed to be used in with a Disposable pattern, so you don't want to manually close the handle with CloseHandle(SafeFileHandle) (just call the Close method, or Dispose , instead).

And as SafeFileHandle is sealed , I really don't see any point in the " public static extern bool CloseHandle(SafeFileHandle hObject); " signature.

---

EDIT

I just googled your book and found one CloseHandle(SafeFileHandle) reference. As expected, it is not used, and the SafeFileHandle is properly closed using:

private void ClosePipe() 
{ 
    if (!_handle.IsInvalid) 
    { 
        _handle.Close(); 
    } 
}

Answer 2

What you see there is the Win32-API function to close an open handle . This function is to be used when you are using Win32-C/C++ and work with system-handles. I cannot validate the above statement a 100% about the CLR, but I guess you will be fine, not to use it.

See the MSDN -article on CloseHandle -function for Win32.

Also there is this article here, which talks about the GC of the CLR.