Limit the no. of requests per second generated by the Dns.BeginGetHostEntry method OR use Task parallel library(TPL)

Question

I have used Dns.BeginGetHostEntry method to get the FQDN for the hosts based on host name (List of the host names is stored in SQL server database). This method (asynchronous) completes the run in less than 30 minutes for nearly 150k records and updates the FQDN in the same table of SQL where the host name is stored.

This solution runs too fast (exceeding the threshold of 300 requests per second). Since the permitted no. of a request for a server to generate is limited, my server is listed in the top talker and requested to stop the run of this application. I have to rebuild this application to run synchronously which now takes more than 6 hours to complete.

//// TotalRecords are fetched from SQL database with the Hostname (referred as host further)
for (int i = 0; i < TotalRecords.Rows.Count; i++)
{
    try
    {
        host = TotalRecords.Rows[i].ItemArray[0].ToString();
        Interlocked.Increment(ref requestCounter);
        string[] arr = new string[] { i.ToString(), host }; 
        Dns.BeginGetHostEntry(host, GetHostEntryCallback,arr);
    }
    catch (Exception ex)
    {
        log.Error("Unknown error occurred\n ", ex);
    }
}
do
{
    Thread.Sleep(0);

} while (requestCounter>0);

ListAdapter.Update(TotalRecords);

Questions:

1. Is there any way the number of requests generated by this method can be limited per second?

2. I have an understanding that ParallelOptions.MaxDegreeOfParallelism does not control the threads per second, so is there any way TPL can be the better option? Can this be limited to no. of requests per second?

Answer 1

Use a SemaphoreSlim with a Timer to limit the requests per period.

[DebuggerDisplay( "Current Count = {_semaphore.CurrentCount}" )]
public class TimedSemaphoreSlim : IDisposable
{
    private readonly System.Threading.SemaphoreSlim _semaphore;
    private readonly System.Threading.Timer _timer;
    private int _releaseCount;

    public TimedSemaphoreSlim( int initialcount, TimeSpan period )
    {
        _semaphore = new System.Threading.SemaphoreSlim( initialcount );
        _timer = new System.Threading.Timer( OnTimer, this, period, period );
    }

    public TimedSemaphoreSlim( int initialCount, int maxCount, TimeSpan period )
    {
        _semaphore = new SemaphoreSlim( initialCount, maxCount );
        _timer = new Timer( OnTimer, this, period, period );
    }

    private void OnTimer( object state )
    {
        var releaseCount = Interlocked.Exchange( ref _releaseCount, 0 );
        if ( releaseCount > 0 )
            _semaphore.Release( releaseCount );
    }

    public WaitHandle AvailableWaitHandle => _semaphore.AvailableWaitHandle;
    public int CurrentCount => _semaphore.CurrentCount;

    public void Release()
    {
        Interlocked.Increment( ref _releaseCount );
    }

    public void Release( int releaseCount )
    {
        Interlocked.Add( ref _releaseCount, releaseCount );
    }

    public void Wait()
    {
        _semaphore.Wait();
    }

    public void Wait( CancellationToken cancellationToken )
    {
        _semaphore.Wait( cancellationToken );
    }

    public bool Wait( int millisecondsTimeout )
    {
        return _semaphore.Wait( millisecondsTimeout );
    }

    public bool Wait( int millisecondsTimeout, CancellationToken cancellationToken )
    {
        return _semaphore.Wait( millisecondsTimeout, cancellationToken );
    }

    public bool Wait( TimeSpan timeout, CancellationToken cancellationToken )
    {
        return _semaphore.Wait( timeout, cancellationToken );
    }

    public Task WaitAsync()
    {
        return _semaphore.WaitAsync();
    }

    public Task WaitAsync( CancellationToken cancellationToken )
    {
        return _semaphore.WaitAsync( cancellationToken );
    }

    public Task<bool> WaitAsync( int millisecondsTimeout )
    {
        return _semaphore.WaitAsync( millisecondsTimeout );
    }

    public Task<bool> WaitAsync( TimeSpan timeout )
    {
        return _semaphore.WaitAsync( timeout );
    }

    public Task<bool> WaitAsync( int millisecondsTimeout, CancellationToken cancellationToken )
    {
        return _semaphore.WaitAsync( millisecondsTimeout, cancellationToken );
    }

    public Task<bool> WaitAsync( TimeSpan timeout, CancellationToken cancellationToken )
    {
        return _semaphore.WaitAsync( timeout, cancellationToken );
    }

    #region IDisposable Support
    private bool disposedValue = false; // Dient zur Erkennung redundanter Aufrufe.

    private void CheckDisposed()
    {
        if ( disposedValue )
        {
            throw new ObjectDisposedException( nameof( TimedSemaphoreSlim ) );
        }
    }

    protected virtual void Dispose( bool disposing )
    {
        if ( !disposedValue )
        {
            if ( disposing )
            {
                _timer.Dispose();
                _semaphore.Dispose();
            }

            disposedValue = true;
        }
    }

    public void Dispose()
    {
        Dispose( true );
    }
    #endregion
}

Sample usage

IEnumerable<string> bunchOfHosts = GetBunchOfHosts();
IList<IPHostEntry> result;

using ( var limiter = new TimedSemaphoreSlim( 300, 300, TimeSpan.FromSeconds( 1 ) ) )
{
    result = bunchOfHosts.AsParallel()
        .Select( e =>
        {
            limiter.Wait();
            try
            {
                return Dns.GetHostEntry( e );
            }
            finally
            {
                limiter.Release();
            }
        } )
        .ToList();
}

Answer 2

A purely async solution.

It uses one nuget package Nite.AsyncEx and System.Reactive It performs error handling and provides the results of the DNS as they occur as an IObservable<IPHostEntry>

There is a lot going on here. You will need to understand reactive extensions as standard async programming . There are probably many ways to achieve the below result but it is an interesting solution.

using System;
using System.Collections.Concurrent;
using System.Threading.Tasks;
using System.Linq;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Diagnostics;
using System.Net;
using System.Reactive.Disposables;
using System.Reactive.Linq;
using Nito.AsyncEx;
using System.Threading;

#pragma warning disable CS4014 // Because this call is not awaited, execution of the current method continues before the call is completed

public static class EnumerableExtensions
{
    public static IEnumerable<Func<U>> Defer<T, U>
        ( this IEnumerable<T> source, Func<T, U> selector) 
        => source.Select(s => (Func<U>)(() => selector(s)));
}


public class Program
{
    /// <summary>
    /// Returns the time to wait before processing another item
    /// if the rate limit is to be maintained
    /// </summary>
    /// <param name="desiredRateLimit"></param>
    /// <param name="currentItemCount"></param>
    /// <param name="elapsedTotalSeconds"></param>
    /// <returns></returns>
    private static double Delay(double desiredRateLimit, int currentItemCount, double elapsedTotalSeconds)
    {
        var time = elapsedTotalSeconds;
        var timeout = currentItemCount / desiredRateLimit;
        return timeout - time;
    }

    /// <summary>
    /// Consume the tasks in parallel but with a rate limit. The results
    /// are returned as an observable.
    /// </summary>
    /// <typeparam name="T"></typeparam>
    /// <param name="tasks"></param>
    /// <param name="rateLimit"></param>
    /// <returns></returns>
    public static IObservable<T> RateLimit<T>(IEnumerable<Func<Task<T>>> tasks, double rateLimit){
        var s = System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch.StartNew();
        var n = 0;
        var sem = new  AsyncCountdownEvent(1);

        var errors = new ConcurrentBag<Exception>();

        return Observable.Create<T>
            ( observer =>
            {

                var ctx = new CancellationTokenSource();
                Task.Run
                    ( async () =>
                    {
                        foreach (var taskFn in tasks)
                        {
                            n++;
                            ctx.Token.ThrowIfCancellationRequested();

                            var elapsedTotalSeconds = s.Elapsed.TotalSeconds;
                            var delay = Delay( rateLimit, n, elapsedTotalSeconds );
                            if (delay > 0)
                                await Task.Delay( TimeSpan.FromSeconds( delay ), ctx.Token );

                            sem.AddCount( 1 );
                            Task.Run
                                ( async () =>
                                {
                                    try
                                    {
                                        observer.OnNext( await taskFn() );
                                    }
                                    catch (Exception e)
                                    {
                                        errors.Add( e );
                                    }
                                    finally
                                    {
                                        sem.Signal();
                                    }
                                }
                                , ctx.Token );
                        }
                        sem.Signal();
                        await sem.WaitAsync( ctx.Token );
                        if(errors.Count>0)
                            observer.OnError(new AggregateException(errors));
                        else
                            observer.OnCompleted();
                    }
                      , ctx.Token );

                return Disposable.Create( () => ctx.Cancel() );
            } );
    }

    #region hosts



    public static string [] Hosts = new [] { "google.com" }

    #endregion


    public static void Main()
    {
        var s = System.Diagnostics.Stopwatch.StartNew();

        var rate = 25;

        var n = Hosts.Length;

        var expectedTime = n/rate;

        IEnumerable<Func<Task<IPHostEntry>>> dnsTaskFactories = Hosts.Defer( async host =>
        {
            try
            {
                return await Dns.GetHostEntryAsync( host );
            }
            catch (Exception e)
            {
                throw new Exception($"Can't resolve {host}", e);
            }
        } );

        IObservable<IPHostEntry> results = RateLimit( dnsTaskFactories, rate );

        results
            .Subscribe( result =>
            {
                Console.WriteLine( "result " + DateTime.Now + " " + result.AddressList[0].ToString() );
            },
            onCompleted: () =>
            {
                Console.WriteLine( "Completed" );

                PrintTimes( s, expectedTime );
            },
            onError: e =>
            {
                Console.WriteLine( "Errored" );

                PrintTimes( s, expectedTime );

                if (e is AggregateException ae)
                {
                    Console.WriteLine( e.Message );
                    foreach (var innerE in ae.InnerExceptions)
                    {
                        Console.WriteLine( $"     " + innerE.GetType().Name + " " + innerE.Message );
                    }
                }
                else
                {
                        Console.WriteLine( $"got error " + e.Message );
                }
            }

            );

        Console.WriteLine("Press enter to exit");
        Console.ReadLine();
    }

    private static void PrintTimes(Stopwatch s, int expectedTime)
    {
        Console.WriteLine( "Done" );
        Console.WriteLine( "Elapsed Seconds " + s.Elapsed.TotalSeconds );
        Console.WriteLine( "Expected Elapsed Seconds " + expectedTime );
    }
}

The last few lines of output are

result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 84.16.241.74
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 84.16.241.74
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 157.7.105.52
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 223.223.182.225
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 64.34.93.5
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 212.83.211.103
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 205.185.216.10
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 198.232.125.32
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 66.231.176.100
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 54.239.34.12
result 5/23/2017 3:23:36 PM 54.239.34.12
result 5/23/2017 3:23:37 PM 219.84.203.116
Errored
Done
Elapsed Seconds 19.9990118
Expected Elapsed Seconds 19
One or more errors occurred.
     Exception Can't resolve adv758968.ru
     Exception Can't resolve fr.a3dfp.net
     Exception Can't resolve ads.adwitserver.com
     Exception Can't resolve www.adtrader.com
     Exception Can't resolve trak-analytics.blic.rs
     Exception Can't resolve ads.buzzcity.net

I couldn't paste the full code so here is a link to the code with the hosts list.

https://gist.github.com/bradphelan/084e4b1ce2604bbdf858d948699cc190

Answer 3

Had you ever considered to use the TPL Dataflow library? It has a very convenient way to limit the concurrent operations of the same type. Also it has an opportunity to throttle whole pipeline by limiting the buffer size .

Basically all you need to create is a pipeline with:

• an entry BufferBlock which will be used to store all your TotalRecords items
• a TransformBlock , which will accept a host and return the results for it
• a BatchBlock which will gather the results and create a batch of results
• an ActionBlock , which finally update your database with results.

So your code could be like this:

// buffer limited to 30 items in queue
// all other items would be postponed and added to queue automatically
// order in queue is preserved
var hosts = new BufferBlock<string>(new DataflowBlockOptions { BoundedCapacity = 30 });

// get a host and perform a dns search operation
var handler = new TransformBlock<string, IPHostEntry>(host => Dns.GetHostEntry(host),
  // no more than 5 simultaneous requests at a time
  new ExecutionDataflowBlockOptions { MaxDegreeOfParallelism = 10 });

// gather results in an array of size 500 
var batchBlock = new BatchBlock<IPHostEntry>(500);

// get the resulting array and save it to database
var batchSave = new ActionBlock<IPHostEntry[]>(r => GetHostEntryCallback(r));

// link all the blocks to automatically propagate items along the pipeline
var linkOptions = new DataflowLinkOptions { PropagateCompletion = true };
hosts.LinkTo(handler, linkOptions);
handler.LinkTo(batchBlock, linkOptions);
batchBlock.LinkTo(batchSave, linkOptions);

// provide the data to pipeline
for (var i = 0; i < TotalRecords.Rows.Count; ++i)
{
    var host = TotalRecords.Rows[i].ItemArray[0].ToString();
    // async wait for item to be sent to pipeline
    // will throttle starting with 31th item in a buffer queue
    await hosts.SendAsync(host);
}

// pipeline is complete now, just wait it finishes
hosts.Complete();

// wait for the last block to finish it's execution
await batchSave.Completion;

// notify user that update is over

I encourage you to read whole How-to section on MSDN to get a better understanding what you can do with this library, maybe continuing the read with official documentation .

By the way, you may use the SqlBulkCopy class to update the database , if it will fit your requirements, usually it's faster than a regular update with SqlDataAdapter .