Which layer should create a HttpResponse?

Question

Do you know why HttpResponse is created in the controller layer? And what will happen if HttpResponse is created in the service layer?

Answer 1

HttpResponse should not be passed to the service layer.

The Controller layer is the conductor of operations for a request. It controls the transaction scope and manages the session related information for the request. The controller first dispatches to a command and then calls the appropriate view processing logic to render the response.

also Is a best practice.