reading from multiple imap.gmail.com from the same fetchmail client

Question

For my portfolio software I have been using fetchmail to read from a Google email account over IMAP and life has been great. Thanks to the miracle of idle connection supported by imap3, my triggers fire in near-realtime due to server push, much sooner than periodic polling would allow otherwise.

In my basic .fetchmailrc setup, in which a brokerage customer's account emails trade notifications to a dedicated Gmail/Google Apps box, I've had

poll imap.gmail.com proto imap user "youraddress@yourdomain-OR-gmail.com" pass "yoMama"  keep nofetchall ssl  idle mimedecode limit 29000 no rewrite mda "myCustomSpecialMDAhandler.sh  %F %T"

Trouble is, now I need to support reading from multiple email boxes, and hand off the emails to other specialized MDA scripts I wrote. No problem, just add more poll lines to .fetchmailrc , right? Well that doesn't work when the other accounts also use imap.gmail.com . What ends up happening is that while one account reads fine (and not necessary the first one listed, though usually yes), the other is getting "socket error" all day and the emails remain untouched, unread. I can't figure out why and not even sure if it's some mechanism at imap.gmail.com or not, eg. limiting to one IMAP connection from a host. That doesn't seem right since I have kept IMAP connections to many separate Gmail & Google Apps accounts from the same client for years (like Thunderbird ) and never noticed this exclusivity problem.

I haven't tried launching multiple fetchmail daemons using separate -f config files (assuming they wouldn't conflict), or deploying one or more getmail and other similar email fetchers in addition. Still trying to avoid that kind of mess--unscaleable the more boxes I have to monitor.

Answer 1

Don't have the reference offhand but somewhere in fetchmail 's docs I recall reading that idle is not so much an imap feature as a fetchmail optional trick, which has a (nasty for me) side effect of choking off all other defined accounts from polling until the connection is cut off by some external event or timeout. So at least that would vindicate Google.

Credit to Carl's Whine Rack blog for some tips.

For now I use killall fetchmail; fetchmail -f fetcher.$[$RANDOM % $numaccounts].rc killall fetchmail; fetchmail -f fetcher.$[$RANDOM % $numaccounts].rc periodically from crontab to cycle reading accounts each defined individually in fetcher.1.rc , fetcher.2.rc , etc. Acceptable while email events are relatively infrequent.