string.find() returns true when ==-1 is used but false when <0 is used

Question

I am trying to find a character within a string but I am getting unexpected results. My understanding is that string::find(char c) returns -1 when it is not found. However, I am getting some unexpected results.

Even though the string does not include an '8' , it is still returning true .

std::string s = "123456799";
if(s.find('8')<0)
    cout << "Not Found" << endl;
else
    cout <<  "Found" << endl;

//Output: Found

However, when using == instead the code works as expected.

std::string s = "123456799";
if(s.find('8')==-1)
    cout << "Not Found" << endl;
else
    cout <<  "Found" << endl;

//Output: Not Found

Answer 1

My understanding is that string::find(char c) returns -1 when it is not found.

It's not accurate. According to the documentation :

Return value
Position of the first character of the found substring or npos if no such substring is found.

So to be precise, when not found std::string::find will return std::string::npos . The point is that the type of std::string::npos is std::string::size_type , which is an unsigned integer type. Even it's initialized from value of -1 , it's not -1 ; it's still unsigned. So s.find('8')<0 will always be false because it's not possible to be negative.

Documentation of std::string::npos :

 static const size_type npos = -1; 

This is a special value equal to the maximum value representable by the type size_type .

So you should use std::string::npos for checking the result, to avoid such kind of confusing.

if (s.find('8') == std::string::npos)
    cout << "Not Found" << endl;
else
    cout <<  "Found" << endl;

---

if(s.find('8')==-1) works fine, because the left-hand operand of operator== here is unsigned, the right-hand one is signed. According to the rules for arithmetic operators ,

• Otherwise, if the unsigned operand's conversion rank is greater or equal to the conversion rank of the signed operand, the signed operand is converted to the unsigned operand's type.

So -1 will be converted to unsigned, which is the value of std::string::npos and then all work as expected.

Answer 2

string::find()返回size_t ，这是一个unsigned int，所以它永远不会是负数。