c select() reading until null character

Question

I am implementing a proxy in c and am using select() to not block on I/O. There are multiple clients connecting to the proxy, so I include the socket descriptor # in my messages so that I know to which socket to forward a reply message from the server.

However, sometimes read() will not receive the full message up to the null character, but will send the rest of the message on the next round of select(). I would like to receive the full message at once so that I will know which socket to forward the reply to (buffering will not work, since I don't know which message belongs to which when there are multiple clients). Is there a way to do this without blocking on read while waiting for a null character to arrive?

Answer 1

There is no such thing as a message in TCP. It is a byte stream protocol. You write bytes, it sends bytes, you read bytes. There is no guarantee how many bytes you will receive at any one time and there is no guaranteed association between the amount of data written by a single write and read by a single read. If you want messages you must implement them yourself. Any given read may read zero, one, or more bytes, up to the length of the buffer. It might be half a message. It might be one and a half messages. What it is is entirely up to you.

Answer 2

Use ZeroMQ if you're doing individual messages. It has bindings for a huge number of languages and is a great abstraction for networking. In fact, it can handle this proxy model for you.