具有深度测试的OpenGL点精灵-混合问题？

Question

I am rendering point sprites (using OpenGL ES 2.0 on iOS) as a user's drawing strokes. I am storing these points in vertex buffer objects such that I need to perform depth testing in order for the sprites to appear in the correct order when they're submitted for drawing.

I'm seeing an odd effect when rendering these drawing strokes, as shown by the following screenshot:

Note the background-coloured 'border' around the edge of the blue stroke, where it is drawn over the green. The user drew the blue stroke after the green stroke, but when the VBOs are redrawn the blue stroke gets drawn first. When it comes to draw the green stroke, depth testing kicks in and sees that it should be behind the blue stroke, and so does this, with some success. It appears to me to be some kind of blending issue, or to do with incorrectly calculating the colour in the fragment shader? The edges of all strokes should be transparent, however it appears that the fragment shader combines it with the background texture when processing those fragments.

In my app I have created a depth renderbuffer and called glEnable(GL_DEPTH_TEST) using glDepthFunc(GL_LEQUAL) . I have experimented with glDepthMask() to no avail. Blending is set to glBlendFunc(GL_ONE, GL_ONE_MINUS_SRC_ALPHA) , and the point sprite colour uses premultiplied alpha values. The drawing routine is very simple:

• Bind render-to-texture FBO.
• Draw background texture.
• Draw point sprites (from a number of VBOs).
• Draw this FBO's texture to the main framebuffer.
• Present the main framebuffer.

EDIT

Here is some code from the drawing routine.

Setup state prior to drawing:

glDisable(GL_DITHER);
glEnable(GL_BLEND);
glBlendFunc(GL_ONE, GL_ONE_MINUS_SRC_ALPHA);
glEnable(GL_DEPTH_TEST);
glDepthFunc(GL_LEQUAL);

Drawing routine:

[drawingView setFramebuffer:drawingView.scratchFramebuffer andClear:YES];
glUseProgram(programs[PROGRAM_TEXTURE]);
[self drawTexture:[self textureForBackgroundType:self.backgroundType]];

glUseProgram(programs[PROGRAM_POINT_SPRITE]);

// ...
// Draw all VBOs containing point sprite data
// ...

[drawingView setFramebuffer:drawingView.defaultFramebuffer andClear:YES];
glUseProgram(programs[PROGRAM_TEXTURE]);
[self drawTexture:drawingView.scratchTexture];

[drawingView presentFramebuffer:drawingView.defaultFramebuffer];

Thanks for any help.

Answer 1

If you want to draw non opaque geometries you have to z-sort them from back to front. This has been the only way to get a proper blending for many years. These days there are some algorithms for order independent transparency like Dual Depth Peeling but they are not applicable to iOS.