Unable to create an array of Python objects from YAML

Question

I am trying to instantiate an array of python objects from YAML, inside a struct. Outside of a struct I am able to do this easily, but it seems that the YAML BaseLoader is failing to recursively search the sub nodes of my object.

import yaml
import ruamel.yaml

class Person:
    def __init__(self, name: str = 'JohnDoe'):
        self.name = name

    @classmethod
    def from_yaml(cls, constructor, node):
        for m in constructor.construct_yaml_map(node):
            pass
        if 'Name' in m:
            name = m['Name']

        return cls(name=name)

    def __repr__(self):
        return f'Person(name={self.name})'


class Car:
    def __init__(self):
        self.passengers = []

    def add_person(self, person: Person = None):
        self.passengers.append(person)

    @classmethod
    def from_yaml(cls, constructor, node):
        for m in constructor.construct_yaml_map(node):
            pass

        inst = cls()

        if 'Driver' in m:
            inst.passengers = [m['Driver']]+inst.passengers

        if 'Passengers' in m:
            foo = m['Passengers']
            print(f'm[\'Passengers\'] = {foo}')
            for person in m['Passengers']:
                inst.add_person(person)

        return inst

    def __repr__(self):
        return f'Car(passengers={self.passengers})'


if __name__ == "__main__":

    yaml = ruamel.yaml.YAML(typ='safe')
    yaml.register_class(Person)
    yaml.register_class(Car)

    data = yaml.load("""
        - !Person &0
            Name: 'Paul'

        - !Person &1
            Name: 'George'
            
        - !Person &3
            Name: 'John'

        - !Car
            Driver: *0
            Passengers: [*1]

        - !Car
            Driver: *3
            Passengers: 
                - !Person &4
                    Name: 'Ringo'

        """)

    print(f'data = {data}')

the above code prints the following to the console on execution:

m['Passengers'] = []
m['Passengers'] = []
data = [Person(name=Paul), Person(name=George), Person(name=John), Car(passengers=[Person(name=Paul)]), Car(passengers=[Person(name=John)])]

where as I would expect the output to be

m['Passengers'] = [Person(name=George)]
m['Passengers'] = [Person(name=Ringo)]
data = [Person(name=Paul), Person(name=George), Person(name=John), Car(passengers=[Person(name=Paul), Person(name=George)]), Car(passengers=[Person(name=John), Person(name=Ringo)])]

no matter what, even with an array of strings, the associated value of the key 'Passengers' is always [] in the dictionary m.

do I have to manually tell the constructor to travers the rest of the node first in the from_yaml function, or does YAML loader work recursively from the bottom up?

Answer 1

I was able to find a partial answer in this post .

In the case of raumel.yaml , it looks like our constructor is the from_yaml function, which gets added when the class is registered. All we have to do is add a yield after the initialization of our class in from_yaml , and before we retrieve our recursive item Passengers .

class Car:
    def __init__(self):
        self.passengers = []

    def add_person(self, person: Person = None):
        self.passengers.append(person)

    @classmethod
    def from_yaml(cls, constructor, node):

        for m in constructor.construct_yaml_map(node):
            print(f'm{type(m)} = {m}')
            pass

        inst = cls()
        yield inst # <-- This yield statement fixes our issue

        if 'Driver' in m:
            inst.passengers = [m['Driver']]+inst.passengers

        if 'Passengers' in m:
            foo = m['Passengers']
            print(f'm[\'Passengers\'] = {foo}')
            for person in m['Passengers']:
                inst.add_person(person)
                
        return inst

    def __repr__(self):
        return f'Car(passengers={self.passengers})'

Answer 2

There is no need to import yaml in your example.

During the construction of the car, its passengers are not yet know. So what you need to do is construct potentially recursive data such as Person and Car in a two step process, first constructing and yielding the "empty" Car then filling in the Driver and any Passangers on the already yielded instance. The loader knows how to handle this, so you don't have to recurse into anything in your from_yaml .

Additionally you'll need to call constructor.construct_mapping(node, deep=True) in from_yaml , instead of your iteration over constructor.construct_yaml_map(node) :

import ruamel.yaml

class Person:
    def __init__(self, name: str = 'JohnDoe'):
        self.name = name

    @classmethod
    def from_yaml(cls, constructor, node):
        inst = cls()
        yield inst
        m = constructor.construct_mapping(node, deep=True)
        if 'Name' in m:
            inst.name = m['Name']
     
    def __repr__(self):
        return f'Person(name={self.name})'


class Car:
    def __init__(self):
        self.passengers = []

    def add_person(self, person: Person = None):
        self.passengers.append(person)

    @classmethod
    def from_yaml(cls, constructor, node):
        inst = cls()
        yield inst
        m = constructor.construct_mapping(node, deep=True)

        if 'Driver' in m:
            inst.passengers = [m['Driver']] + inst.passengers

        if 'Passengers' in m:
            foo = m['Passengers']
            print(f'm[\'Passengers\'] = {foo}')
            for person in m['Passengers']:
                inst.add_person(person)

    def __repr__(self):
        return f'Car(passengers={self.passengers})'


if __name__ == "__main__":

    yaml = ruamel.yaml.YAML(typ='safe')
    yaml.register_class(Person)
    yaml.register_class(Car)

    data = yaml.load("""
        - !Person &0
            Name: 'Paul'

        - !Person &1
            Name: 'George'
            
        - !Person &3
            Name: 'John'

        - !Car
            Driver: *0
            Passengers: [*1]

        - !Car
            Driver: *3
            Passengers: 
                - !Person &4
                    Name: 'Ringo'

        """)

    print(f'data = {data}')

which gives:

m['Passengers'] = [Person(name=George)]
m['Passengers'] = [Person(name=Ringo)]
data = [Person(name=Paul), Person(name=George), Person(name=John), Car(passengers=[Person(name=Paul), Person(name=George)]), Car(passengers=[Person(name=John), Person(name=Ringo)])]

Although it is allowed to write the tag followed by the anchor, it is IMO more appropriate to write the anchor followed by the tag, because you'll get an anchored instance of the tagged object.

So that leaves me wondering what the name is of &2 !Person (probably the same as for !Person &2 ), is it Pete?