JTextField problem with ActionEvent getModifiers method

Question

When I hit the enter key into a JTextField and I'm pressing one modifier key (like Ctrl or Alt) the ActionEvent is not fired and thus I can't check the modifier key just pressed.

Why is it a bug?

Answer 1

For Swing widgets, key binding should be done through InputMap and ActionMap (although the "obsolete" registerKeyboardAction is simpler). See Keyboard Bindings in Swing in the old Swing Connection, and the JComponent API docs.

The Pluggable Look & Feel rather gets in the way of mapping input events onto actions. Exactly what happens with ActionEvent is up to the current PL&F. Application code directly registering KeyListener generally isn't a good idea in Swing. Some components are made up of other smaller components, meaning InputEvent s may or may not get passed on. Input events may get interpreted to perform more than one operation. Generally the whole thing is a mess.